Granted, he hasn't shown a lot of penetration in attack, (who has?) but is second in the tackle count at Leigh this season, and hasn't got injured or suspended. On those criteria, he could be argued to be one of our better signings!

Just my opinion Col, and I'm not privy to the rankings of the pay list.But again I have my thoughts.

Everyone should be on a high tackle count - Our completion rate is low, i.e poor discipline, drop ball, Poor kicking game, it all adds up.

Never/Rarely first in a tackle, opposition look for him close to the line as he waits for someone else to take the impact - just watch the 3rd Huddersfield try as an example of many more this season. Easy to do big minutes when you take nothing out of yourself or the opposition. On a par with 2005 imports imho, when we reach hey lads hey time soon then you would not want to rely on him keeping your job for 2018