I base mine on leigh being less effected when penky is not on the field [that's also a fact

That is your perception of the game and on the day watching it live I may have agreed with you, but the actually game video and points balance doesn't support that.
For me PR got it dead right.

for me he didn't,it let them back in the game when leigh were in control
good win well deserved but wrong decision

I don't need to talk to any of the players to understand that they wouldn't want to come off especially playing well in a final.

If I was Penky I'd be happy with the two medals I've won this year, and keep doing as my coaches say.

Classy Player types Leigh, not us/we, but (from it's previous posts) seems to like Leigh East, Penky & Brian Bowman......proper confused !!!!

It's the off season, more confusion expected

aye Glow....you are reet !

I said leigh and not us for all the none lethers who may have viewed this post

Edit to make sense.

Was wondering when the first negative posts would appear I will order the coconut


.

Anyway why argue with anyone enjoy the trophies we have won (masterminded by a coach who makes wrong decisions

) and all the games again on Leigh Centurions TV

We scored more points with Bob on and won 36-12 against a very strong Fev side.
What you are also ignoring here is the a game plan that was probably always meant to bring a fresh Penky back on to run at and finish off a tired Fev in the last 15 mins.
That went slightly sideways with the carding of Penky but we still did it with a tired Bob Beswick.
Penky or Beswick is something I've wondered about and watched for all season. As a result I took the time to watch the final game video with a view to just that (after seeing it live and watching it once just for the fun of it). My perception on the day was weighted towards what you initially said but a game review looking at that aspect shows for me that PR got it right.