Cheers

I'll be interested to hear whether the first try chalked off was a good call

Was told he dropped the ball in the tackle.

The ref was on the spot so he saw it and gave the correct decision.

On balance I thought Thaler was pretty good last night and kept the game flowing.

All the officials had a good game last night, I would,nt mind that standard every week

When did touch judges stop looking for massively forward passes then, I am not referring to borderline forwards here

Yes indeed - Leeds 3rd try of the match looked a clear cut forward pass from my position in the North Stand. Obviously the ref and asssistant were in a far better positions but I was convinced that it was just a matter of time before the ref would pull them for it. I could not believe it was allowed to stand.

Thought Thaler let the game flow last night - as did Leahy at Sheffield - and surely that's what spectators want? (Granted a flowing game did us no favours last night!

)

As for McNally's disallowed effort, the touch judges weren't happy with it either, so we have to assume the officials got it right.

And finally, on the topic of forward passes, he's not the only ref to let them go, but remember, Leeds had a late try disallowed for one and, if you check back on McNally's disallowed effort, I think there were two of them in the move that put him through.

I'm happy with the ref that let's the game flow and the players seem to prefer that too.

I suppose Moore passing the ball a good 2 seconds after Thaler had shouted held and not giving a penalty but getting Moore to play the ball good reffing. Also the Leeds player who clearly played at the ball - knocking on - inside his own ten and Thaler not giving as back to one good reffing. Both these happened yards from him. Blatant wrong decisions that could have cost us a try and gifted them field position from where they scored. Thaler is poor. Oh forgot about Jonny Pownall knocking the ball out in the tackle and not playing at it where he gave it as back to one where they scored.

It is correct reffing and I would dispute your 2 seconds.

There is a new rule were if they fail to hear " held " and pass the ball they are just told to play the ball, but we heard held, Moore didn't

I was at the back of the north stand and I heard it. If it had been a short time before he had passed it yes but Leigh were retreating ready to defend the play the ball. It should have been a Penalty to Leigh Reffy.

You are possibly correct but the rule was brought in because players were unfairly penalised when passing the ball at the same time that the ref called held. I think this way is better.