Useless, not fit to play for England, terrible attacking/defensive stats..............it all works out the same in the end. You don't want him to play for England because he is now a Warrington player. You don't want him to play for England because the England coach is the Warrington coach. You don't want him to play for England because he has replaced a Wiganer in the team.

That's what it comes down to at the end of the day. Plus I see you've not denied the part about bannings on your board.

IMO, I couldn't care less if Smith picks Myler or Tomkins or McGuire or Eastmond. All I want is whoever gets picked to work together as a team and push England to beating those ***** from down under.

All this whining and complaining about players being picked over others is just pathetic. If you're a proper England fan, you would get behind the team selection no matter what.

Do you hear me whining about Carvell being left out of the squad? I'm not happy about it, but it's Smith who picks the team and I've got confidence that he's picked the right players for the right game.

I'm not going to go and and moan and start a stupid thread saying that Carvell should have been picked, that Smith is out of his depth and that I'm never supporting England ever again.

Sorry I really couldn't help myself. I hope I am proved wrong and look forward to the internationals, although it would be a bit preferable to have a coach not related to a team, because we are just ending up with the referee problem, if he does pick his players he loses, if he doesn't he loses. Not a nice place to be in. Still don't think Mylers defence is good enough though

If this is sarcasm...
Personally I rate Ratchford as much as I do Tomkins and Eastmond. Very good player for his age, could develop into something. I hope Salford keep him.

Not in the slightest. We mullered Salford at our place, but he was a different class even in defeat. Difficult to get a tackle on him and really directed play, even when he was in the centres.

The maturity of his play belies his years.

Good, I wish we could see him in a good side though, hopefully Salford will build around him and give Wire/Wigan/Saints good matches in the future and only lose to Wigan

Best kicking game out of the new guys too imo.

I also seem to recall a ton of people losing their top-scorer bets the year after... He was in hot form and there weren't any in-form wingers at the time to be fair, let alone english ones.

I agree, but what would be your stance if Myler plays well score a couple of tries and creates a couple more in a m.o.m. performance, whilst McGuire has an average to poor game, only for Myler to be "rested" for the next game in favour of Tomkins.

Here's what I posted on the Wigan site.

"The only thing I will say about the Tomkins omission is that I hope Smith has the balls to take Sam to one side and explain why he has made the decision.

It could be that he wants to give other players a go who haven't played since the grand final.

I do think that Sam will play at Wigan."

I would have loved us to have signed ratchford. Brilliant player

I think that may happen as well.

Far too many people jumping the gun just to moan and have a go at Smith an the comp aint even started yet.

Well 12 months ago, Tomkins wasn't even part of the Wigan first team, so lets give him time to develop and show he can play consistently to a high standard.

Tony Smith made him look like an amateur in the semi final.

Well to begin with, if that was the case, there would be a lot of red faces on here, especially in the Wigan and St Helens RLFANS camp.

In all honesty, I would consider that a strange decision. You would have thought in that situation that McGuire would have been dropped in favour of Tomkins. However, at the end of the day, it's the coach's decision. It would be a big gamble though.



I agree. However, I can see Smith being the kind of coach who would do that.

I agree Tomkins should have probably been given the nod - but who knows he could have picked up a slight knock.The thing I dont like about Tomkins is that he is a petulant little so and so and can lose his rag at the drop of the hat.A little bit of sledging and he is put off his game.Look at the Semi against us , they were all winding him up especially King and Clarke and he could not take it.Look at the cricket and the Aussies are past masters at sledging and I think the Rugby team would be much the same.