No he's should be in the England squad, and he's better than Monas and Roby..... Honest

If we're after a new hooker I don't know why we don't trey and buy Lincoln Withers from Crusaders, superb player who hasn't been snapped up yet! If we sign Withers or McShane personally I would sell Higham and keep Clarke as a hooker/second-row utility...

I'm fairly sure Withers is going to Hull KR and will replace Fisher.

McShane's a good player, but coming here he would still be second choice so I don't see what the value is for him. He's certainly a talent and deserves better than having to wait behind the ineffectual Buderus.

McShane has been stuck in the U20s a few time this season don't think he's going to take up much cap.

Withers is 30+ I think and although he's a fine player in a poor side I wouldn't think he's a player God would go for. Not sure about McShane either but have seen little of him. Plus points are he's young and British. If TS thinks he would do a job at the HJ then thats fine with me.

I'd be happy with this, get's in some cracking kicks from dummy half and is always dangerous. Fit's in with our signing policy at the moment of good, young, british player.

There may be some substance to this. Warrington have rated him since he ripped our Academy apart years ago.

I would be happy with mcshane as our interchange hooker... lets face it, we need a new one.

Isn't Buderus rumoured to be going home, though?

100% yes from me. Combines the best of Clarke and Higham and is young.

I think it would be a good signing. We can lose Higham and Clarke can go to no3 hooker as McShane comes in as no2 hooker.

I'd be really happy with this if there'a ny truth in it, he's someone that's impressed me when I've seen him.

Millward likes to take Higham with him wherever he goes, so try to make this happen again. We know now that Clarke is Widnes bound, I think we'd all be pretty happy with McShane providing the support act for Monas whilst learning from him.

He has a hell of a long kicking game with that left peg of his.

Had a very good game against us last year at the HJ.

This all over, he was great in that game. Got a good all-round game and will only learn under TS, here's hoping theres substance in it now clarke has gone.

1000% yes from me if true. Great young British talent as already mentioned and offers so much more off the bench than one trick Mick.