Wane would of always had the pick of youngsters joining Wigan same as St Helens have. With our academy starting to produce young players and the training facilities at Warrington, I think Powell could win the grand final with us and with a more attractive style wane would play with

Powell for me. Wane did some very good things with one club having inherited a ready-made squad and a winning culture. I’d really have wanted to see what he could do at another club before we gambled on him.

Powell had a decent blooding as temporary Leeds coach followed by turning around Featherstone. He then had a very average Castleford squad that he repeatedly seemed to get the best out of. I think last season he suffered from the Tony Smith syndrome. He’s just been there too long. You don’t see Wigan or Saints persisting with a top coach that long even after a couple of trophies.

As for the moaning, who cares. Focus on the play and turn off the TV during the after-match and interviews.

On a separate note, our youngsters coming through look to be the best all-round potential professional athletes we’ve had for years. And we seem to have a few in all the key positions - Dean, Thewlis, Roebuck, Robson, Longstaff to name a few. I’d love to see what Powell or Wane could do with these guys.

Powell is not where this club should be and that appointment would be a poor one and show a real lack of ambition. It will be a British coach and Wane is the best solution. We have an unbelievable academy structure and have invested heavily in that, Wanes record bringing academy players is second to none together with his winning record and mentality.

Incidentally , Wane . May not want the job to be fair .

Given the same players and resources would the trophies won by each read the same as they currently do? I don't think so personally. Would cas have been better recently with wane in charge? Again I don't think so. Its hardly a fair comparison to compare head to head is it?

I don’t mind Powell. I’d be happy with either but would take Wane out of the two.

At least with Powell we’d be able to watch some great attacking rugby.

I would prefer Powell personally, but I do agree I'd be happy with either. Wane was the most likable Wigan coach of my lifetime after Millward. Powell can be a hit miserable after a loss but I am as well usually, I wouldnt really want our coach to be chirpy after a defeat but to have our players playing like Powells cas teams when fully fit, yes please.

If Wire “play the Wire way” in 2021 and end up finishing top of SL and winning the GF, like Wigan did under Maguire, to then be succeeded by assistant Shaun Wane, shouldn’t Wire offer the position Price vacates, in the same way, to Henderson?
Only saying.

From what we've seen that's a big IF. The key in succession planning is success.

However I agree that succession planning in any business let alone sports club is something to strive for you've only got to look at the boot room mentality at a certain association football club in the 70s for a blueprint.

It’s a good point, all fans do it. All the fans on here wanting Wane we all hated him at Wigan but will have him here in a heartbeat, and yes Powell looks as happy as turkey at a pre xmas drinks party but we would be on his side if we thought we had reason to be.

At least it'll keep the forum ticking over, regardless who we get we can always rely on a few future threads saying we should have gone for Wane/Powell /AN Other instead.

oh yeah the last thing you want to hear is "I thought there were a lot of positives in the way we played..." for the fourth week running during a losing streak

Powell took over a team that was bottom of the league in 2013 and in 4 years had them top of the table.
He didn't have the budget to bring in big name galactico signings, and they were still a selling club. During that 4 year revival Cas lost their best player three times, (Rangi Chase, Daryl Clark, Denny Solomona) and Powell still kept improving them, and playing good attacking rugby too.