I haven't seen him play any games this season, so I'm not commenting on whether he would be a good signing or not, however if he does sign for the Wire, I would back Tony Smith's judgement rather than some on here, who seem to be relying on things they watched several years ago.

After going to watch Swinton this evening I was reminded of one thing about Kevin Penny; he scores tries that send a shiver down your spine and to be honest are tries I'm not sure anybody else is capable of scoring.

Doh!

Go on then - marks out of 10 for his try v Williams and Mendieka's efforts. Which was the best?

From what I remember ...(every try is a good one)

Penny - 7/10 loose pass from nanyn picked up on halfway by penny and ran diagonally under the posts - no one got near him.

Williams 9/10 - nice chip kick from Burke (corrected from harvey) turned the defence, gathered in on the burst by Mendieka who fed on to Williams to run in to the corner.

Mendieka - 5/10 dropped on a blocked grubber kick.

Penny has been excellent all year but in the last 5 weeks and with a run in the team Williams too has been excellent.

Mendieka certainly has an eye for a try at this level.

Ps Rhys Evans won man of the match at full back.

Evans is back playing again?

Yes.


From swinton website - Rhys Evans, the Warrington dual-reg player, will come in at full-back for suspended Ritchie Hawkyard and David Mills will return to the pack.Chambers added: "Rhys has been training with us for a few weeks and he will be a straight swap for Titch."

Stats do not always tell the full picture but here they are

Swinton Top 4 try scorers to date


James Mendieka played 16 tries 10 goals 0

Ryan Shaw played 18 tries 9 goals 38

Kevin Penny played 27 tries 9 goals 2

Rhys Williams played 15 tries 9 goals 0

So make your own minds up.....

Penny is a better kicker than Willams

I do think you rather play-down Penny's try. Admittedly it followed a crap bouncing pass but the way Penny scythed through the defence and rounded the full-back without anybody getting within a dicky of laying a finger on him was something special and is the kind of play to get a crowd on its feet and tingling with excitment.

The Williams try actually came from an "off-script" last tackle play and it was actually Burke rather than Harvey who chipped through.

Either way an enjoyable evening (with quite a few Warrington speccies in attendance), I might even drop in at Whitehaven to see if Swinton can stay up if I'm up in the Lakes that weekend.

ooo I dunno, it doesn't state how many each of them have missed!

He'd probably have scored more goals but the centre teed them up wrong.

My two penneth..I would like to see him given another chance. As previous posters on here have said, he had that certain indefinable 'something' that made you sit up and take notice.

Hey, it might be a primrose-tinted and YES I KNOW about the previous defensive frailties but he will be commanding a lot lower wage than he did in the past, (and he must have learnt SOMETHING during his time away) so where is the risk, I would plump for him over Williams any day.

aye, a winger is only as good as his centre presents him the ball.

Was not meaning to undersell the try and was commenting of the overall try and not just the player finish. Penny is lightning fast and game changer. The majority of his tries this season have been long range and in open/broken play he is a frightening prospect for the defence.

That said, Williams has worked hard for the team over the last few weeks and with a settled team has proved a good finisher too.

Most importantly I am just glad that people enjoy watching Swinton and rugby at Championship level.