If you looked at his highlight reel for the MoS awards his play is top draw against Salford, Hull KR, Wakefield and Huddersfield but not one clip against a top four side.

Therein lies the problem with current scoring for MoS award, compounded by the shortened season this year.

I would have him behind Roby, Powell and even Clarke in terms of performance at hooker this year.

His family is happy about it, so that’s reason enough and good enough for me. No one stands out a long way....so I’ve no complaints. For sure, no one at Wire deserves it.

Glad the opinions on here are the same as mine. I've been called some very funny names on Twitter, including on DMs by some Super League players for suggesting he isn't the best player in Super League this season.

In the first few games Cas did well and McShane did well. Since lockdown both he and they have done absolutely nothing. It's just a bizarre decision and just sums up the competition and the sport in this country. It's falling apart so rapidly under Elstone that you have to wonder what will be left in a few years. It has been said that Ellery Hanley picked the winner because they decided the points system wasn't fair because of the uneven number of games. He chose McShane as the best player in Super League. Hanley is the same guy who wanted Saints to release Keiron Cunningham and sign Sean Penkywicz.I'm not sure he's the best judge of a player's ability.

Out of all of the players nominated coote would have been my pick followed by Farrell. French getting man of steel nominations because he scores fancy tries shows how bad MOS has gotten in the voting.

So your opinion on the game is in line with Warrington fans on an internet forum but the guys who actually play the game think differently 4.16259765625:5