Exactly.

Yeah, just making the point its not his usual position and he would probably be wasted on the wing, as IMO fullback is a more important position.

Wasted on the wing???

It certainly didn't look asif he was wasted on the wing in Origin.

I'll take Craig Bellamys opinion over yours.

Whats he got to do with it?

I meant Meninga.

Fella, Inglis used to play wing for the Aussie's, despite probably being the best centre on earth. Where players play during rep games isn't always their best position, I've seen Karmichael-Hunt play interchange in Origin, does that mean he's naturally an impact hooker/half? Or is it pretty certain that he was a full back?

If we signed Boyd and played him on the wing, he'd be wasted because he'd be the best full back in the league.

This is the point I was trying to make

Cause IMO fullback is a more important position and his best position. Like the previous poster, if he did sign for Wire or any SL club, why have potentionally the best full back in the league on the wing

You make a very valid point there

As a Warrington and Sale Sharks fan, I would be slightly disappointed to see Doherty sign for Warrington.

Would much rather keep Penny, and try and work with him. Plus there are younger players coming

Doherty is a solid player. Good tackler, high workrate. He would certainly be a capable League player.

Sale signed him from Wasps, who picked him up from Leeds. Wasps won the Heinken Cup that season.

But he lacks any real class, and has failed to take chances, that you expect wingers to score. Having said that he has played for a dreadfully coached Sale team for the past few seasons, and has probably only been passed to 5 times in two seasons.

He's still a young man, who hasn't quite furfilled his early potential. Maybe Smith could bring out the best in him, though just don't quite see it.

Whats wrong with Ben Harrison?Quality player and probably lot cheaper.I still wonder how you get all the quality players you have under the cap.

easy

He isnt a natural 13.. although he does get used there now and again... Ben is a prop.

Agreed, he is a prop and will get better and better in that position. I would like to see a really good 13 and one outside back and I think we will have an excellent squad for next year.