Same old story with some of our posters on this site. Any chance to run a Warrington player down. No doubt they will quote themselves as 'realists' but when push comes to shove it's the same old stuff with just a different players name in the post.

I presume you didn't watch the challenge cup semi finals then??................where I would say they both looked totally out of their depth!!

Myler looked way out his depth playing in the quater final against us and the league game against us. He went missing.

I wouldn't class this as a fair assesment.

It's not just about 1 or 2 games, Tomkins has looked amazing in high pressure games that Myler has not even come close to playing in yet. But on the other hand Myler has looked great in a poor team with poor players around him.

they are both good young players but you have to take into consideration that tomkins has been playing with a much better team than myler

Make your mind up, have you seen him or not, I think not to be honest.

Some would say it's easier to stand out in a poor team. He was the 'go to' man for Salford so maybe this is the case, he saw alot more ball than most young players would.

I wish you would be the GO TO MAN. Go to your own Feckin forum man. I have no bother sleeping after reading your posts on here.

Why not debate the issue? It's a forum.

Its a perfectly fair assessment.

I was replying to the comment in which the guy said "in the games I have seen Tomkins and Eastmond have been a cut above"

I suggested that he hadn't watched the CC semi finals then where I thought they both looked inexperienced and lost.

But hey ho don't let that stop you having another stab at Myler!

TBH I can see quite a few people are getting fed up up with all the tedious remarks of odemwingie and Rogues Gallery. I have a feeling they will be gone from this forum very soon.

What do you call Internationals? Big games are when the big game players come to the fore.

You say that as if i contradict myself. Let me rephrase it for you as you seem to be struggling with the concept. The times i have seen Salford play prior to our interest he's not stood out that i have noticed him. Since i learned we had interest in him i've not seen a lot of him so i used Englands game to see what we are getting. To sum up, i have seen more of Tomkins and Eastmond than i have Myler and i have been impressed with the other two but not by Myler.

That's unfair.
I'm not mad on the odemwhatsits but Rogues usually brings a lot of valid points to the table and tends to know his stuff.
People of Warrington aren't the brightest bunch and just seem to abuse back.

he knows his stuff ,listen put thompkins in myler in eastmond in give them all a game cos we are not going to beat the kiwis or the aussies so whats all the bull talk about anyway