What about the next half?

I DIDNT SAY HE WAS GOING, I SAID IF], AND IT WAS A REFERENCE TO THE FACT THAT WE HAVE A GOOD SQUAD ON PAPER NEXT YEAR.

Look at the team tonight and tell me how much overhauling is needed for a complete refresh? This team is the result of an almost complete refresh, I believe in most of the players who have played the last couple of weeks and aside maybe a few pack additions that's next years team! But the coaching staff are failing to get any performance out of them. Can't defend, can't attack, can't manage a game, most importantly they don't show any belief, sadly I thinl Powell has lost the confidence of the dressing room, even though its now mostly a dressing room that he has assembled. Maybe now is time, or at the very least if we lose the next 2.

To be fair he has succeeded in changing the culture and mentality. The previous culture saw us crumble in the first round of the play offs. This new culture sees us crumble at the first score of a try by any opposition.

Lets hope we survive this season and there is a big slice of humble pie waiting next season for those of us who have blinked first and started to lose faith in the project.

If you read my original post from August last year, I was concerned about his appointment then.
I really don't take any pleasure in seeing this season unravel with him in charge.
We may still improve, so be it, I will be happy if I am proved wrong. But for the club and the true supporters, not for the way Powell has decimated the team and its performances. I don't accept his way of managing people, those days have gone. And it doesn't work does it? Look at the evidence. Like you say, be honest.

Answer me this: should utd got rid of Fergie after 1 season? Should Huddersfield have got rid of Watson last season?

Things are incredibly disappointing this season, but it doesn't matter which coach you bring in, you have to give then time. That's what the successful clubs do. Even yourself, who obviously posseses great prophetical judgement, won't really know at this stage given all the changes.

The issue is, how much of a threat is relegation, and if you think it's real, then there is a strong argument to get someone else in.

If not, despite the disappointment, its pointless getting someone else in, especially when he has brought in so many new players.

unfortunately I can't give you a good argument. This team even being picked apart and rebuilt should have picked up more wins. I suppose I'm in for a penny in for a pound. I'm usually in the get the coach out camp when things are going so wrong but I'm hoping that this seasons pain will give us a better long term outcome.

Quick question, does anybody still want Thewlis to be starting full back again anytime soon?

He's having a bad few weeks undoubtedly, but we've all agreed thats the trade off in blooding youngsters.

But the senior players? Not an ounce of love for the jersey some of them and the ones that have can no longer transition it into winning rugby.

Absolutely shocking performance again. There was a burst of optimism when we went up by a few scores and some good runs from the forwards. But how on earth can we go from forcing a drop-out, to conceding a penalty and conceding a try in the next breath. Once they were 4 behind, we all knew what would happen.
I don't see any progress week on week or any signs of what they are doing in training. Truly, truly shocking. That was a must win game, the million pound game is a real possibility now, and I can't see us winning that against a determined side.
This is as bad as the Anderson era.

Which ones have no love for the jersey?

Ferguson won the Scottish league and cup winners cup (with Aberdeen) showing a clearly superb pedigree. Powell has won a meaningless LLS and then bottled 3 finals

Fergie was nearly sacked after 2 seasons. That's 1.5 years longer than you're giving Powell. I'm not defending Powell tonight though. But even the most short sighted must realise that any coach tasked with changing the culture at a club with a raft of changes will need more than half a season.

So who would you have brought in? Plenty of captain hindsights on here but only one person in the past two weeks has made any suggestions.

I'm still awaiting a poster to provide the name of definitive coach who would have 100% made things better. Unless you you know 100%, which no-body will, you have to give the coach a reasonable amount of time.

Powell is staying anyway. Its crap at the moment, but you and everybody else are going to have to stomach it.