I am not saying he has been a bad asset to the team but I think we could do better, there are a few things about his core skills that I really can't get enthusiastic about. He certainly still isn't the player he was at Leeds.

Then again, look at Vinnie Anderson last night and the loss of his pace. Remember the try he scored at the Millennium Stadium a couple of years ago?

Back to the original topic.

IMO Blythe had a shocker. Lots of errors and seemed a liability when he had the ball. to be fair the lad has not had much first team action this year and i imagine it can be hard to just slot in and be upto spead. Saying this, FWIW i dont think he will become a stand out SL player. I'm not sure he will make the improvements needed but i hope he proves me wrong.

Pickersgill seemed fairly anonymous tonight, could reallt fault him but i dont think he really stood out either. Again it cant be easy slotting back into a team when you have been playing elsewhere for most of the season.

As we are on the subject of mathers, I really rate the guy. He might not make the most breaks on kick returns but as someone has shown with the stats he does make good yards, Lots of tackles and few errors. Add his positive attitude and communication skills he seems to have on the pitch, especially with the wingers then i think we have got a top class bloke.

Pickersgill was only on the pitch for 2 small stints so how on earth you can start slagging the lad of is beyond me. He's a good forward and a real nice lad and i hope we see him sign a permanent deal with us next year. Likewise Penny i thought had a reasonable game and did what was aksed of him. Warrington's sliding defence was shocking at times and Wigan always had the numbers.

Blythe i agree was poor.

Also loving the stats Tickle, but Mathers offers so much more...he demonstrates behaviours that I hope all of the team will eventually adopt. His enthuasium is amazing (him and Penny must have about 10 red bulls before a match, as they just seem so pumped), love how he celebrates errors we have forced, big hits, the first one to slap a player on the back when they have messed up...that stuff is just priceless. It's the TS effect. Speaking to Leeds fan at last years millenium magic after a disappointing first half, I moaned about our lack of togetherness - players never celebrating tries or forced errors, going off as indivduals at half time. Leeds fan stated that Leeds were like that before TS was there.

In my eyes Mathers signing and Tony Smith appointment are the best things that have happen this year...oh and Wembley

Rant over..sorry

I've a feeling he'll be on the bench. TS never leaves him out if he's fit. Any chance Mickey Higham might make the final?

Dave T's stuff is good. He's really raised the bar over my perfunctory statistical analysis. I must do better I bet though he gets vexed off like me when people selectively adopt / reject the validity of stats to suit their arguments.

If they were able to display what percentage of each team's salary cap every player was on, that might make comparisons between given individuals a bit more realistic.