Having Hughes is a waste of cap space whether Jason Clark is here or not.

This might be an unpopular opinion but I hope he stays. He is solid in defence and in attack more often than not gets a quick play of the ball which opens up the game for us. Although I would love a team of superstars it's clearly not possible.

God I so hope not esp when players line Mamo have gone.

Same goes for Ashton, looks like they are both staying by the looks of it

He absolutely doesn't get fast play the ball.

Who would folk rather have Hughes or j Clark..tough choice

Hughes, mostly because i expect him to be slightly cheaper on the cap.

I'd be delighted if Holmes and longstaff was our second row partnership next season. So nether for me!

Can I rather be kicked in the nuts repeatedly, it would be less painful.

Very good..only asked cos they're so alike..for me Hughes cos he offers a bit more versatility.i.e can play stand off and centre when a crisis arises

The only possible justification for not having currie as your first choice 2nd row next year is that you want a more attacking 13. He is our best back rower by a long way at the minute.

Currie, Hughes, Holmes, Davis, Clark and Longstaff quite happy with that battling It out for 11-13.

We just need a top class prop for me.

I'd play him at 13.

I don't mind keeping JC for another year and I would get rid of Hughes. Makes little ground, stops every attack in its tracks.