Insert yourself into the laughable bracket mate. Graham or Morley? Morley. Graham or Carvell? Carvell. Sorted. Next? Graham as an impact prop though, thats an entirely different proposition.

I like James Graham and I especially like the way that he is used as virtually another loose forward however if to get James Graham we have to loose either Morley or Carvell to get him then no thank you.

He doesn't offer anywhere near as much of a lift or offer as many breaks as those 2.

How is he used as a loose forward Geordie? (not a trolling attempt a genuine question). He is our go forward, i wouldn't say he links our backs and pack. He often runs to the line and passes to put a man through a gap but that is good play. I haven't seen anything else to remotely suggest he plays like a loose forward.

hmm but Geordie come on, have you seen the missed tackle count from those two? Grahams also got years and years left in him, if people wouldnt swap either of them tomorrow to get graham on a nice 4 or 5 year contract I think they're mad.
Bit unfair really though because all three are different types of players, very different

Graham over Carvell any day of the week.
Can't see it like, still is abit of a rumour that won't go away.

James Graham passes the ball sometimes. Wow. Is it not obvious to anyone with half a brain that maybe opposition defences would be lining up two or three defenders to put a shot on Graham and, therefore, it makes so much sense tactically to have him hit an X-ball, drawing in another defender or two to the unders line runner, thus theoritically leaving space for his halfback to run at the line and use the ball?

I wish more teams did that, it's simple, but very effective Rugby and is hardly new, nor cowardice or lack of impact on Graham's part. Quite the opposite to be fair.

Look at the ages of both Graham and Morley, think beyond Week 1 of 2010 and still tell me you wouldn't have him.

Giddiness is reaching laughable proportions for any of you who think you would be better off sticking with what you have got rather than signing James Graham

Maybe Warrington could stick Gareth Carvell on the wing to exploit his pace wider if they cannot fit Graham into the team anywhere else?

He'd be a better winger than Fancis Meli

So would Kevin Penny!

Saints will have the strongest pack next year imo

Fozzard and Hagerty

Who wouldn't?