I've said it before and I'll say it again, Dave king was a second row that we played as prop, due toinjuries, he got spell in the back row just before the seasons end and was pretty good.


GeorgiaLlis was just also getting into some form when he got a season ending injury.


Mike Ford was a let down, I doubt many people remember us signing him in the centenary season, when Mackey went back to Australia. He was shot as a player and his confidence was gone

The difference is that all the above mentioned didn't have the ability whereas Currier did, the thief!

Tony Tatupu is a challenger for my worst signing nomination.

Let's make it clear, GOB isn't a bearing on where this thread is going.

GOB is doing OK....had a good game but just needs someone to share the load and the confidence to tell players what he isdoing

I could not resist the opportunity to put together a worst imports 19 (because 2 of the 17 were always injured)

1 Doc Murray (but who was the full back we signed on loan from Trafford Borough )
2 Graham Appo (on his final season)
3 Manoa Thompson (his son is not bad though)
4 David Kidwell (who went on to be a great 2nd row)
5 Leon Felton
6 Tom Oreilly
7 Matt Rodwell
8 Craig Tietzel
9 Mike Sullivan
10 Roy Asotasi
11 Don Duffy
12 Paul Marquet
13 Steve Georgalis
14 Steve Jackson
15 Mark Jackson
16 Steve Roach
17 Chris O Sullivan
18 Matt Sturm
19 Scott Wilson

Some players are not bad they just can't be d when they join us. Good ability, awful attitude.

Steve Roach was the laziest prop and the most intense prop I've ever saw in p&b. one extreme to the other!

It's bizarre how Parsley's name comes up on these 'worst signings ever' threads.

He joined us from Lancashire Lynx who were the worst team in the lower division and used to lose by 70 points every week.

He played one game for us, when we smashed Hunslet in the Challenge Cup, and didn't get another game.

He was hardly Mr big name signing, considering we signed Langer, Nikau and Gee that off season, but his reputation seems to have endured as a 'flop' (I wonder how many people actually were at that Hunslet cup game and can remember what was so bad about him....)

This is the problem with attitudes towards lower league players. You always hear people say we should be looking in the lower leagues for signings but when we have signed players from the semi-pro league they just get described as crap straight away and written off, while they are adjusting to going full-time professional. It happened with Kevin Crouthers and Matt Sturm too, or when we brought Warren Stevens back from Whitehaven when he was still only about 22.

OK maybe Parsley didn't set the world alight on his debut but who knows how he would have been if we had given him a bit of a chance? As it was Lee Penny was preferred to him all season and then we released him and played Lee Briers and Allan Hunte there instead!

Last I heard about Parsley was a few months ago he'd got appointed conditioning coach for England RU so he seems to have done OK in his post-rugby career.

Didn't he win Gladiators?

Gareth is 5th in the whole of Super League for try assists, thats an impressive stat for someone who isn't always a regular, he's a good kid who you should hold on to.

Maybe we can headhunt him to replace Chris Baron

+1

i think the fact that Smith rates Declan Patton very highly will have had some bearing if GOB leaves.

The next year or 2 will probably bring a quality new HB and hopefully the emergence of patton at 7.

which leaves GOB somewhere else.

It seems that I have unexpectedly and unintentionally ruffled some bona fide contributors feathers by my observations. For which I unreservedly apologise.
In my defence I would plead that I have never proclaimed myself a true supporter. In fact, after fifty years of following the wire and Rugby League in general, I am probably a somewhat jaundiced supporter if anything. But at least my contributions are based on objective rather than emotional observations. At least I hope so although I cannot fully guarantee it.
I also plead that I have never 'knocked' Richie Myler. In fact I have been at pains to point out that, when contributors have been having a go at the half backs, it has usually been because the pack have been under the cosh and have not provided the platform for the half backs to perform.
However there seems to be a general opinion that Richie's form has not been the best this season. This may be due, as you say, to injuries, or it may be due to external factors affecting his mental approach. To me, he has been somewhat distracted this term and I put my contribution forward as a possible explanation. Time will tell if I am talking out of my arris or not.
However if exception was made to my assertions of profligacy at the BBC, I do not deny one syllable of what I said, but this is not a question for discussion on this thread or board.

I thought GOB had a good game against Huddersfield. I thought his kicking game was excellent. There were times when he was not expecting the pass and knocked on but this is down to a lack of understanding tactically which will come with more game time. As I have said before, to me he is the most instinctive scrum half we have, I just worry about his longevity given the head shots he keeps taking.