The major flaw currently is that players don't get the recognition for being "league leaders" in the form of a medal/ring. As individuals Warrington players have ended the season with jack, that's certainly wrong. As for giving "league leaders" similar kudos to being "champions" i couldn't disagree more. You've only done half the job after 27 games and if you can't finish it off you don't deserve to be classed as champions.

So do the team that didn't do the 'first half of the job' deserve to be called Champions.

We did the "first half", we finished in the eight. The second half is becoming champions.

Really? Can you imagine the explosion if at the end of the season Manchester United are told that they get nothing for winning the Premier League and have to go through a knock out competition to be claimed champions? And then get knocked out in the last round by Aston Villa, who finished 5th - 13 points behind. Sir Alex would have a fit!

The play-offs and grand final have been manufactured to take the fans hard earned money and completely devalue the season's efforts. The attendances would suggest that people have got wise to this and just see it as an end-of-season party at OT! The LEAGUE champions were always the ones who finished top of the pile at the end of the season - until the play-offs were introduced of course. The premiership competition didn't hold that much weight yet it was more or less the same thing - an end of season knock-out competition.

We've only had the play-offs for about 12 years, and already, they're descending into a competition not worthy of name.

We currently have a system, where, over half of the league, go into a play-off system...crap

None of the top two teams are contesting the final...not sour grapes by any means...well done Stains and Leeeeeeds, you've done what you had to do....

Spectator interest is poor....I mean, come on....a Wigan Stains derby, in a stadium that holds circa 15000, not selling out for a crucial game..THAT TELLS YOU A LOT

PLAY-OFFS !!!!! Yeah, lets keep 'em, but call it the Premiership

Even the attendances of GF night are massaged
I remember well, the Bradford v Wigan 2003 GF, when Stevo said "fantasic night for RL, full stadium, and not a single ticket given away on a freebie....." CONKERS.....I was in there on one, as a mate of mine was playing for a University RL side that year. He couldn't make the GF due to a family party, so he gave his FOUR tickets away to me and some mates. Multiply this by 20odd players per team, and how many University/College teams entered...add this to the may other freebies which were given away (there were loads)...FULL HOUSE MY BOTTOM....we're being brainwashed by Sky, to believe this is the be all and end all...it's not. We had (have) the league...that's where it begins and ends.

N.B. IF we win the GF next year from whatever position we finished in the league, I'd still say the same.

None of the 90-odd thousand at the Aussie Rules Grand Final today were moaning that the team finishing top of the ladder should have more right to call themselves 'champions' than Geelong, who won the Grand Final over Collingwood who actually finished top of the ladder at the end of the regular season.

And IIRc, they have a regular home & away season ... If you want something simple, go watch soccer.

I have never had a problem with the playoffs and the grand final before this season. It's a tremendous concept and only brings more publicity to our great game ...so i wont change my tune because it doesnt look right for Wire, unfortunately its tough

and it is a great game Ian St John (former LFC player) was Raving about the game on Radio city today while they were discussing the pansy-ness of modern footballers. He did mention union players as he admitted to like both codes but he asked the other guys in the studio "did you see Warrington Leeds last night What a game"

anyway just because we lost out at the final hurdle we cant criticise the system. If they scrapped the grand final the very first thing fans would say is there is nothing for the mid table teams to play for. Then fans would clamour for relegation to be reinstated or a third cup competiton ...both backwards moves...

What we should never ever do is compare our Game to football in any way shape or form its a rotten game, and the less like it Rugby League is the better...

what we've got works very well i would imagine 60 odd thousand fans next week will prove that theory

Everyone's favourite footballer, Joey Barton, was waxing lyrical about the entertainment value in the Wire v Leeds game last night and saying he couldn't wait for Saints v Wigan. They need to jiggle the format somewhat, but the showpiece final has to stay.

Nice to see people are waking up, the play off system is a ludicrous way of quantifing the league champions. As far as i have been concerned the team finishing top have always been the league champions. The play offs to me are a seperate comp that should carry no more prestige than the challenge cup. Unfortunately our media led sport stuff's down our throats the idea that it is the pinnacle achievment, defying logic.

It is what it is and its here for the forseeable future, so without any intention of being rude, please just get over it.
Again, sorry about this, but when you actually get to a grand final (and lose 4 on the trot like saints ), you know how important the GF is to teams and fans alike.
In 2005, 2006, 2007 and 2008 we came top of the league but every saints fan I know thought we had won jack s8it. The GF was all that mattered to us.

Its only a matter of time before wire get to the GF after all, unless lord tony smith gets bored and goes off somewhere.

No problem with the playoffs and the GF but I've always said that the team that finishes top of the league deserves mopre credit than they get at present. The playoffs are just the premiership with a ton of Sky money chucked at them.

At least two people mentioned the NFL system in their posts as a comparison. At least in that sport the division champions get recognition as do the conference champions. The Superbowl is a whole different spectacle.