Definately, signed for Wigan whilst recovering from a broken arm, but didn't recover quickly enough. Was let go and re-signed for us without actually playing for Wigan.

Didn't Joe Ropati have two spells with us?

Kohe Love was the one most wanted back but he was a different player 2nd time round. His step and pace had gone after his injuries at Hull and Bradford.

Paul Sculthorpe - oh wait, no.

Matty Blythe
Lee Mitchell
Tyrone McCarthy


Like what I did there.

Wait for Boxing day announcement!

Yes it was funny how Toa was hero-worshipped after he had left. He ticked all the boxes for being a hate figure, ie he had been good with us first time round, he then signed for a club who was better than us at the time, but who we didn't really like, and he left us at his peak (or as it turned out after he left, his peak had been with us first time round). I was as guilty of this as the rest of the Wire fans, I still hero-worshipped him. Something about Toa was teflon he managed to retain his cult hero status after quitting us for a rival, where other players would have been hated.

Remember all the buzz when he was linked with coming back to us at the end of Cullen's first season, before signing for Bradford, we got him back a year later. Like you say the cutting edge had gone from his game BUT in fairness to Toa, his defence was a lot tighter. He wasn't a bad player second time around, just not the dangerous attacking force of old.

Quite a big list this. Especially over the last 20 years or so. Is it that we are such a great club and players jut loved playing for us or were we offering more than the going rate elsewhere?

Had the cutting edge gone from Toa's game or was he starved of any decent ball on the left edge. Maybe the truth is somewhere in between but the right side has seen a lot more quality ball than the left side over the last 10 years