TBH I was shocked we renewed his contract a few months back. McCarthy was hyped up beyond belief on here before he made his first grade debut, he has had about 10 first team games now and has not lived up to it at all, even Mitchell and Blythe have both had their moments at Super League level.

I've watched Leigh many times this year when they've played on Thursday nights and he seems to struggle making an impact in the Championship.

he's probably played about 5 in total.

Just checked the SL website, he's played 7 Super League games, he played in the cup final last year too, so there's 8 without bothering to check the earlier cup rounds in 2009 or 10, or add the pre-season first team games he's played in.

I said "about 10".

Mathers
Hicks
King
Atkins
Riley
Briers
Myler
Morley
Monaghan
Carvell
L.Anderson
Westwood
Harrison

Higham/Clarke
Wood
Solomona
Bridge

The down side of not picking up many injuires? (I know you had Bridge, Myler, Carvell on the sideline for a while)

These guys must have thought they would get plenty of game time this year, didnt McCarthy play at wembley last year? Shame for them.

Contrast my team, Wigan ,have had a bad time of it with injuries this year and have managed to give 6 acadamy lads first team debuts.

Fact is we've both got good depth in our squads and its hard to keep all the players in it happy.

From an outsider against saints I'd play the same team you did a Wembley, no Myler.

Mathers

Hicks
King
Atkins
Riley

Briers
Myler

Morley
Monaghan
Carvell
Louis
Westwood
Bridge

Clarke
Wood
Solomona
Harrison


bridge at loose to act as a playmaker alongside briers myler monas and mathers. harrison at prop/second row when he comes on, same with solomona, wood at prop, clarke for one of briers myler monaghan and to flick back and to between half back and hooker.

dont know how people can say drop riley, hes got a hatful of tries and his partnership with atkins has really took off, same with kingy and hicks which is why i would put bridge at loose as the ball playing loose forward we need.

I think Tony Smith will go with the same team that won at Harlequins and save the other lads for a must win game

I think we should go all out. That week off is crucial especially if it's a bruiser, then if Wigan lose we have the advantage of Clubcall that won't make a difference though as we can only pick Wigan or Saints. Personally I'd go all out to win.

EDIT: If we lose to Saints, and it's close we could face a potential banana skin against FC or Hull KR at home, I think we'd win it but who wants the additon of an extra game, where injuires can happen...?

Yes - need to go all out to win and for once I think we will - last game at KR etc etc.

It's a toss up between Bridge and Riley in the backs.
Then Monas / Myler in the halves
Then Monas / Clarke in the forwards
Then Clarke / Higham as sub hooker
Vinnie / Bridge / Cooper as sub 4th person.

Depends how TS wants to play it.
After Fridays showing Bridge has made a strong case for himself and I'd favour him over Vinnie slightly.
Cooper will be in if we want more power up front.

Wouldn't be surprised if the team is as Wembley apart from Bridge at centre for Riley and Myler missing out.
King at left wing would certainly blunt the high ball to wing option for Saints.

If Riley plays the Bridge should be 4th sub taking over from Vinnie.

An abundance of options.

haha like the fact he is such a good player he gets 'the' before it

I've been thinking the same .... at this rate we'll end up with second rowers covering all positions, it'll be like having DVDV back in charge!

Mathers

Hicks
King
Atkins
Riley

Briers
Myler

Morley
Monaghan
Carvell
Louis
Westwood
Bridge

Clarke
Wood
Solomona
Harrison

This is an all round strong team, with good options. On the McCarthy, Mitchell and Blythe front, non of them have excelled at Leigh. Watching the Sky matches they dont stand out from the Leigh players, which is not a good sign for their longevity as Warrington players. In their defence the Super League squad have stayed fit and healthy, which must be a pain.

Whoever TS announces for Friday is good enough for me, and if my nan gets in the squad.....there will be a bloody good reason he chose her.
ISWT

Wire should go all out for a win this weekend as in 3 weeks time they could be facing a Saints team with a fit Eastmond/Lomax/Soliola/Fa'asavalu rather than without/half fit versions.