You don't have to be 'very clever' or 'very wise' to see when a team is about to throw a victory away in a big game... Although you are correct, I am very clever and wise.

Gidley kicking game was terribl etoday, when we had Hull on the rack in the first half, and their forwards looked like keeling over he kept pointlessly kicking it into touch.

What is the benefit of doing that, they get to rest (apparently at every scrum in the final a 5 minute rest is mandatory) and regain some energy.

I can also see why Sandow wasn't wanted in the NRL, his game management is terrible, was completely anonymous in the last 30 minutes, less said the better about his defensive efforts.

I thought Clarke was excellent, always impressed with him... again our lack specialist players, fullback and wingers let us down I feel. Why Ratchford just let the 40/20 sail past him ill never know.

Sandow has a habit of going awol in games.No doubting his ability but he needs to be like Rob Burrow was + still is for Leeds always running at the opposition.

I've just watched the tries again. No wonder I'm losing my hair. Both of their tries came from kicks that we barely contested.
FFS, this is a Challenge Cup Final in it's latter stages, with a slender lead, not a blow out against bottom of the table with a 40 point lead.
Both attempts, we were like a timid bloke at a 1930's tea dance excuse me.....not good enough.

Buckets of money spent, and we've now lost 3 finals on the bounce. We need to regroup quickly, and make sure we get something out of the season.

Mark Sneyd MOTM?......seriously? No wonder people think standards are slipping. I could think of half a dozen players more deserving.

That judging panel must surely have had a big bet on Sneyd.Nowhere near motm.Could name half a dozen from both sides before him.

They always tend to give them to those type of players, like when Briers, Gidley or Sandow etc get MOTM when they haven't done much.

Feel sorry for so many players who worked so hard today. When we look back at it, Clark, Hughes, Currie etc were immense and our right edge of Evans and King was rock solid. A game ultimately decided by kicks - we missed two shots at goal and failed to deal with two kicks to our left edge. In that sense we didn't deserve to win. If we want to win at Old Trafford we need to be more clinical. Nevertheless, a great advert for the game, just hope we can pick ourselves up for the rest of the season.

Fully agree KT.
I really don't think anyone should feel bad about how they played.
It was all about inches.
Toby stood up well and George was very impressive, but all the lads deserve credit. They'll be hurting for a few days but they certainly haven't let themselves down.

It didn't really run your way today. To lose Gidley who I think is your calming influence was massive and then Westwood went off and others like Ratchford looked to be carrying injuries and struggling with the intensity of the game.

In a strange way I think today will help you to kick on in the league. It's easy to relax when you've won a trophy and to tail away but that clearly won't be the case now. I think you'll have a massive tilt at Old Trafford now.

Houghton was man of the match....however....
Sneyd...40:20 on the fifth tackle....Hull score from the next set...kicks conversion from near the touch line...chips to the corner...regathers and puts Shaul under the sticks....kicks winning goal...match winner.

through a missed kick is gutting but not worrying.

We can't win them all and 3 out of 4 is nothing to sniff at. Hopefully we can nick the LLS off them now at the back end.

3rd major final defeat om the bounce. I guess if go you get to the GF it's more like ''we can't lose them all''.

IMO your lads gave it all on a very humid day, nothing in it at the end, thought Hill Clarke and Russell with his broken field running caused us problems,

I'd rather have 4 trophies and 3 runner up medals in the last 8 years no matter the order they came in, than what we got in the prior 30 years. It was a wayward goal kick and the loss of two very influential players and Hull's resilience that did us today. I'm not worried. We're still very much in contention for the remaining two so that'll do.

You were class today guys on the train home. And indeed your coach Tony Smith was superb in the build up.

Quite possibly one of the most bizarre games ever in a final. You dominated the ruck almost throughout but our lads never know when they're beaten. It's the first time I've experienced a game played in a sauna and to be honest the heat spoiled the game.

You're a great side well coached with some talented players. I have a feeling we'll meet again. Hull have so much negative history with the cup but for once this was our day. We'll enjoy but your side is a credit to you. Great to see some alternative names in the frame.