Was it Solomona who was the victim of a bad tackle to the knees in the CC semi final a couple of years ago ? Protection needs to be given to players joints though by RFL directives if only for the fact that allowing such play to continue will result in an even bigger shortage of players in our game.

This *tackle* has been outlawed in American Football for many years. The first time I saw it here was on TV in a Saints vs Wigan game on TV about 3 seasons ago when Sam Tomkins attacked the left knee, side on,of Keiron Cunningham. Cunningham didn't seek retribution but gave Tomkins the evil eye.

Case Number

ON/729/13



Name

Harrison Hansen



Club

Wigan



Shirt Number

11



Match

Warrington v Wigan



Competition

Super League



Date

05/10/13



Incident considered

Dangerous Contact in 53rd minute (Ratchford)



Decision

No charge



Details of Charge / Reason for NF

Player tackles opponent held in the tackle however contact is around hip/lower back area, and is contribution from teammate in outcome of tackle

So you are using the disciplinary panel details to try and make your point?

Is this the same disciplinary panel that everyone is up in arms about because they have only charged Westwood with 1-2 games and the same disciplinary panel that everyone in RL thinks is a joke?

Where the cap fits and all that.....

Come on, Tomkins doesn't do things like that..............everyone knows that.

Shocking tackle. Was at the very least reckless and it certainly looked intentional. Everone on the ground went ouch when they saw it. McGuire brought it here, I hoped it had gone away, it has no place in RL

His failure to bend his back properly meant he didn't hit as low as he was certainly looking and intending to.

Yes it was. That was against Wigan as well. He was ripping them apart at the time, but had to limp off after the tackle.

Apologies if this thread has died a death but I've been working away from a pc for a while.

I just want to ask why you posted this? The legality of the tackle isn't in question, the potential to cause injury from that type of tackle is!

I made a point a while back in that shoulder charges were legal only last year and, if someone had been hurt through receiving one last year, it would have had the same outcome from the disciplinary panel........it doesn't mean it wasn't dangerous though!!!

Let's just ban tackling as it can easily cause injury; see J. monaghn.

Just as stupid an argument as you lot whinging about a legal tackle to the hip/lower back. Talk of a shoulder charge! Hardly surprisising you don't know the meaning of that either seeing as how so many of you saw two tacklers on Ratchford before Hansen tackled him.

He bent his back as far as he needed to make a legal tackle around the hips. Ratchfords damage is to his ankle ligaments. I don't know if he was wearing blades but they appeared to get stuck in the turf as he felt the force of the tackle. The cannonball tackle is usually one from the side that hits the knee/lower leg, Hansens certainly wasn't one of those.

-legal tackle or not ,if you watch it back you can actually see the *intent* in his eyes when he went in for that *tackle* on a player who was not only already held in the first tackle , but was also--stationary-- at the time of the second *tackle* !sooner that type of tackle is banned the better imo.

I’m not going to get too involved with the Hansen tackle debate because it doesn’t seem to be getting anywhere and just seems to be divided on which club you support lines, having said that I must say that your “you can actually see the *intent*in his eyes” is the most bizarre reasons for thinking there was any malice intended. I can only say like everyone else if a player does a tackle deemed bad enough to be classed as career ending to another player, that player should have the proverbial book thrown at him. End of.

Go away you strange fellow.

Hanson's effort to grab any part of Ratchford's lower limbs was feeble to say the least & he actually made contact with the shoulder on Ratch's back/hip ,the shoulder then slid down towards Ratch's knees & Hanson's arms missed the legs altogether.