I too have wondered about whether we could do with a passionate motivator as Captain a la Andy Farrell. I’ve got the utmost respect for Hill but when the chips are down in a Gramd Final and we’ve just gone behind with minutes to go I’d prefer someone who could stoke fire in the bellies of the players.

On press day it looked like Ratchford was sat in the usual captains position in the team photo I saw.

Easy solution is to make Hill club captain and Roberts team captain.
Hill has the call on trophy pick up.
Or is that just too easy?

Well I'd go with that.
Ratch team captain and Hill club captain.

I don’t think Price has seen enough of Ratchford to know whether he is the Captain yet. They’ve only just returned to training. If I had to guess I’d say it’s Hill in Price’s thoughts until we near the start of the season and then maybe he’ll lump for someone he thinks might add a bit more towards the resilience he’s craving for. Ratchford is a good communicator with a good rugby brain but I’m not sure he’s a leader of men. He didn’t look commanding when in the halves in the big games. Currie is probably on the cards for the future though with his history. Wonder if Clark has the right stuff?

These pre season camps make me smile, whether they're in 30C temperatures in The Canaries, slapping on the Ambre Solaire, or some bleak Welsh mountain range, having a 200l drum of freezing cold rain water, tipped over you, as some kind of forfeit for losing a team building session.
Gimmicky cobblers.

Have players working on technique. Championship winning players are dedicated. They work on their game constantly. Train hard, win hard. Ellery Hanley didn't need to go to the Brecon Beacons to be the best of his generation. He didn't urinate his career up the wall. Dedication. Practice. Training. That makes a sportsman. Not pratting around on a Krypton Factor style assault course,

A leader of men would help, too.
Whether they're international greats, Boyd or Morley, or localish lads Cullen(as a player) or Gregory. They commanded respect and got it. Blow as much smoke up Hill's bottom as you want, he's not a leader of men.

It might be seen as a gimmick but it’s a good way of initiating players into this new regime - a sort of kick up the backside. It may not affect players skill-wise but it does draw a line under the previous technique of espressos on the balcony before a run up the beach in Tenerife. Price is setting his stall out and saying “with me you’ll work hard and work together for each other - no easy ride. If you don’t buy into my resilience philosophies I’ll find other players who will”. Ryan Atkins talks about it here: https://youtu.be/8CIuAEWAZY8 I’m impressed with Price’s approach on things performance-wise. Let’s hope he’s as good a tactician as Smith was and we could see a good couple of years from this team.

It might be seen as a gimmick but it’s a good way of initiating players into this new regime - a sort of kick up the backside. It may not affect players skill-wise but it does draw a line under the previous technique of espressos on the balcony before a run up the beach in Tenerife. Price is setting his stall out and saying “with me you’ll work hard and work together for each other - no easy ride. If you don’t buy into my resilience philosophies I’ll find other players who will”. Ryan Atkins talks about it here: https://youtu.be/8CIuAEWAZY8 I’m impressed with Price’s approach on things performance-wise. Let’s hope he’s as good a tactician as Smith was and we could see a good couple of years from this team.

Very welcoming.

Melbourne Storm must have done something similar. The army camp training was one of the first things that Michael Maguire organised for the team when he came to Wigan in 2010.

I don't blame Psycho if he turned down an invite to this preseason bonding.

I don't have a problem with them doing intense fitness work in the off season, but you don't have to do it in the pitch black up rocky hills with uncertain footing. All it takes is one wrongly placed foot and a snapped ankle and a player's out for half the season or more.

Anyway I'm not going to get too worked up about it at this point, we will find out whether the pre-season work was good or not when we watch them in the regular season.

Different approaches to pre-season get seen as genius or gimmicks depending on how the team plays. In recent years, Hull KR and Salford have been on these army camps, had media stories about it in the off season, then still went on to have rubbish seasons.

Lefty brings up an interesting example with Hanley. Hanley didn't bother with gym work. He designed his own fitness programme based around circuits and a medicine ball, and played squash. He was his own personal strength conditioning coach, sports psychologist, video analyst, and contract negotiator. These days clubs hire all sorts of people and the players have everything prepared for them but I wonder how many have the personal initiative to work out what they really need to do to get the best out of their careers. Hanley was probably seen as a man apart by his team mates and coaches but will have got away with it because they knew he could be trusted to prepare himself in top condition for everything.

Shaun Edwards methods were different but he was out of the same mould of single-minded intensity at preparing himself. Imagine having a dressing room with those two, plus Dean Bell, the example that would set to the others. If we had those three now in our team now we would win everything like Wigan did. But in terms of natural talent I don't think those three were anything abnormal in the world of rugby league, probably some of our current squad have got a better range of RL skills than they did. They just were on a different level in terms of intelligence and drive.

John Woods never trained.
He walked his dogs over the hills by Leighvery day and had a very long almost injury free career...not to mention one of the most naturally talented British footballers ever.

The doubt the army camp adds much to the skill and physic levels of the players.
However team bonding and a brother sense will be strengthened.
I'm not sure a holiday environment creates that ethic.

Have to agree with this, I don't think being captain suits hill, he spends far too much time complaining to the referee and getting involved in the niggly stuff giving away silly penalties. He is best left to concente on his main job which he did with aplomb at the world cup for England (with no armband to worry about).

Club captain definitely, but I'd rather someone else on game day so we can see the best of hill again. I wouldn't be surprised to see Cooper given the nod by Steve Price.

Yes I’d forgotten about Cooper, great call. Local lad, intelligent and disciplined.