Firstly i think Morley will win MOS especially if Wire win the cup and have a good run in the play-offs.

However, Graham is the best prop forward in the league by an absolute mile.

Why would you prefer Carvell, Morley or Peacock when Graham passes the ball [iand[/i makes a hell of a lot more yards than any of them as a clasic prop forward?

Anyway for comparison here are the key stats for them all.

Yards.
Graham- 4049
Peacock- 3135
Morley- 2673
Carvell- 2280

Tries.
Graham- 6
Peacock- 4
Carvell- 3
Morley- 1

Carries.
Graham- 562
Peacock- 433
Morley- 329
Carvell- 273


Offloads.
Graham- 23
Carvell- 22
Peacock- 19
Morley- 12

Tackle Busts.
Graham- 50
Peacock- 40
Morley- 29
Carvell- 20

Defensive

Tackles.
Peacock- 660
Graham- 511
Morley- 419
Carvell- 380

Missed Tackles.
Morley- 44
Carvell- 41
Peacock- 27
Graham- 22

Errors.
Graham- 14
Carvell- 10
Peacock- 9
Morley- 8

Penalties.
Peacock- 14
Carvell- 12
Morley- 11
Graham- 6

You are correct. If the MOS is given to a forward it would be impossible to overlook Graham who has been outstanding this season.

I think Hodgson may win it he;s been great this seaso..

Good shout

But he does play 65 minutes per game ... Thats why his stats are so high ..

If this is correct then the 65 minute achievement only further strengthens his case.

Isn't that a positive?

It depends how you interpret the stats. Graham has made more metres, but has also played more games due to injuries. His metres per carry are the lowest of all four props, with Morley and Carvell averaging a metre more than Peacock and Graham on every single hit-up.

Graham's a good prop in a dominant team and gets the opportunity to play at the line due to the amount of attacking St Helens do.
Morley is also a good prop but has probably had to make more hard yards coming out of his own half given the relative performances of the two teams.

On form, I'd never pick anyone above Morley as he has the extra inspirational quality in a way that Graham can never have until he has performed in the biggest stages.

Lining up alongside Morley you know you are playing with someone who was dominant in the NRL against the best of the best and is widely respected by everyone in the game. If you asked Gus Gould etc what he thought of James Graham the answer would be not much, as when Graham went to the world cup he was invisible.

Whoever is the best, its not by much, there's some top forwards around



Because Morley's the most legendary forward of his generation.

Carvell is in with a shout of winning MoS. He has been massive for us this year.

IMO Morleys improved performances are due to the presence of Carvell. Last year Morley was getting hammered by the opposition but now Carvell has taken some of the hammer.

I really hope we sign another beefy prop for next year, our frontrow will be the best in SL.

Graham doesn't make more yards. He makes less yards per carry than most of the big props.

The difference is that Saints have no rotation in the front row, meaning that he plays for a hell of a lot longer than any other prop in the league, hence being top.

The accurate measure for metre making is metres per carryisn't the best metre making prop, not by a long way.

EDIT: In the past few years we have seen Terry O'Connor, Jamie Thackray, Danny Nutley sit around the top of the metre-making list, were the Saints fans singing their praises then?

That makes it even better surley

Jammer, Moz, Carvell, all worthy of the gong pal, all of em. Jammer deserves it for playing 1000 games in 12 months and being from "the pool"

Ha ha, surely that's reason to keep it well away from him!!!

TBH, I have no major issues with him getting it (only Morley for us is in with a chance), I just get frustrated when people come on and quote the metres made stat as justification, when it doesn't tll the full picture.

Graham is immense for Saints, Morley is immense for Wire. Morley has been instrumental in taking a team of under-achievers through a tough quarter final, and then a massive semi-final. Morley could easily get it.

Could well do indeed and the whole of SL would applaud the chap, after a shaky start at the wire, and being a balloon head in that first year he has become much more mature and a destroyer of men, the captain knock was a bonus and sure made him wake up and front up ... Kev Penny young player of the year to maybe