The Cas incident was worse IMO because of the rumpus kicked up by Powell

Very surprised he didn't cop a ban for that. It was very deliberate and his third clear (and sly) shoulder charge of the night.

The RFL disciplinary committee's report states he made a valid attempt to tackle? I can only assume then that shoulder charges are back on the menu? No arms involved, just point of shoulder onto the base of Wilkin's skull. Dangerous? Yes. Reckless? Yes. Shoulder? Yes. Deliberate and unnecessary contact with head only? Yes. I'm not sure what criteria the RFL use, but it's all got very weird over at Red Hall this year. The impact wasn't very severe so I'm not suggesting any more than 1-2 games depending on his rap sheet, but to suggest it was a valid tackle is bizarre.

I would have to toss a coin to decide whom out of RD and Saddened are the 2 biggest tools on the entire forum, their both full of it!

Which may or may not be true, it's all about opinions I suppose.

However, according to the number of posts accredited to your user name, a mighty 7 in a year and judging by the quality of this one, a coin might not be the only thing you're tossing?

Bloody hell, wilkin looks good for someone that was unconscious, and twitching and then spent a night in hospital due to a head "injury"

He didn't even get a concussion related 7 day mandatory rest.

9 minutes, exactly the same tackle as Atkins last week, no penalty

Was there a load of twitching from the tackled player? Or did he just get up and get on with it because he's not a total ?

Players getting tackled and staying down waiting for the video ref is really getting on my goat now...

Saints players lack of commitment last night compared to the Friday before was obvious. Old 'Poundland Jack Black' even questioned the attitude of his senior players. Catalan outplayed them from start to finish.

Didn't player power get rid of Royce Simmons ? Maybe a few bad apples in the barrel.

There's only really two constants in the team from back then.

Roby and Wilkin.


HMMMMMMMM

I know which one of those 2 thinks the most of himself and he is one of the most overrated players in rugby league (the other is very good, seems to be a model professional and is recognised almost yearly in a certain shortlist). I really hate seeing wilkins punditry, maybe he is who PJB was talking about in his bitter rant last night? There could be a bit of a situation between them?

Well you see the thing is Mr Smart Ass, I had an account previously with quite a few posts and I forgot the password, I asked for help with it but none was forthcoming, so I re registered and do not post much as this forum seems to be populated by people not unlike yourself with smart mouths and I do not want arguments with people because I can not be bothered, but those 2 are particular lacking in much of the way of positive postings without to resorting to some cabbage that they spout, something that I have noticed YOU too can be particularly fond of as well, so I am sorry that I do not post endless clap trap just to get my post count up.

I do not particularly claim to know you but I have come to the conclusion that mostly the space between your ears is a total vacuum and the need to take any notice of a relative of an amoeba is very low down my list.

Carry on .

right, handbags away ladies.

Brokendreams, what was thy previous username?