For the first time I'm actually thinking that TS needs to be replaced ,any other coach would be gone by now

Time is running out for Gaz. I suspect he'll be here next season purely because he's contracted, if he wasn't he would almost certainly be joining Asotasi, Bridge, Wheeler and Myler (worked his testicles off today) at the job centre.

I've never really rated GOB to be honest his kicking game is so hit and miss its ridiculous.. One good kick ( the kick off which forced the drop out) followed by Zero other good kicks.
With ball in hand he either just ships it on to the next player or gets caught in possession, thus killing the momentum.
He's had players like Briers,Johns,Bridge,Myler,Ratchford all around him to learn from and been a regular first teamer for a while at Wire. Add to this long loan spells at Cas,Widnes and Saints but he still looks very average and a long way off being the HB to take us where we want to be.
I hate to sound so harsh but sorry Gaz your time should be up at Wire.

How anyone can be a big fan of gob is beyond me, and I include his mum in that. He's consistently ruddy awful but wasn't as bad as Dwyer yesterday who was abysmal.

Whilst this thread is about our half back can I just mention Lee Briers - it is getting really, really embarrassing having him on the pitch so often during a game.

If he was a coach at any other club playing against us then this board would be in meltdown! And if he's doing this under instruction from Smith, which he obviously is, then it is all the more embarrassing........ he was organising the attack and defence yesterday!!! He could at least wear a water carrier T-shirt as some form of disguise, but oh no, he has his Coach T-shirt on.

Come on guys, someone else on here must surely cringe when they see him come on?

Alan Langer does exactly the same thing for Brisbane...though he does carry water bottles and a towel to make it less obvious! !!!

Any hooker of acting half would look poor behind a beaten pack.

That doesn't explain some poor last tackle options he took. Can we add ormsby to the not good enough list as well, slow beggar.

I totally agree with your sentiments, and the majority of your post.

However, I am a little uneasy with the Gidley signing, & sincerely hope that he doesn`t end-up being our Asotasi equivalent, playing in the backs.

Like Asotasi he has had a great playing career in the NRL, but Old Father Time is catching up, or has caught-up with him.

We will find out next season.

Thankfully,we have learned one lesson from the Asotasi fiasco........ Gidley has only been allocated a one year contract, with a further option, which will be taken-up or not, based on his success in his initial season.

We were found wanting for pace again Myler worked hard O'Brien had a few half breaks but they couldn't go with Kelly's pace, he also thinks quicker, Monaghan looked in discomfort when caught from behind, Hypothetical but had Penny got that ball it would have been a different outcome, but that was a selection call.

Fortunately all seems to be being addressed for next season but let's hope they don't forget the pack.

Had he not been a local lad GOB would have been long gone

Watching a Newcastle match just a couple of weeks ago they mentioned the fitness of Gidley. ..they said .After 15 seasons in the nrl he still tops their pre season bleep test.. .. that's quite impressive.

After watching Asotasi most of us fans need a bleep machine ...the useless @#$##@...

Disappointing 'today'? Been disappointing for two years.

I agree with one of the earlier posts, you cant expect your half backs and hooker to perform behind a beaten pack. Wilde put in a good tackling stint, but he was never going to trouble the opposition in the same way that Westwood can. For me the semi final was lost last weekend as a result of Russell's injury and Westwood's citing (with special thanks going to Daryl Powell).

This.

Same team as last week Penny in for Russell we'd have won. G'OB and Myler were great against Cas....mind you so was the pack and the rest of the team now I wonder is there a connection?