Agree 100% it was a cracking atmosphere Friday night

brought up at wilderspool been watching the wire for 35 years plus but times change dont they

Battered by a pack that was more aggressive, powerful and intelligent with the ball.

Forget about the backs, Myler and Bridge had no chance because nothing was going on up front. Monaghan has been dodgy for a couple of weeks, Harrison and Carvell are far better players than they showed last night.

McGillvary is a real talent but the way he runs head on without any attempt to evade the man is going to lead to him getting a serious injury. Even if Morley had stayed perfectly still McGillvary's head would still have run straight into his shoulder, despite Eddie's bleating.

First cup final we, in my opinion, were out of our depth - but we made it there.
Second cup final, agree we choked on the day as we didn't have enough big game players.

Our squad has grown and changed dramatically since that 2009 defeat, which for me was epitomised when we beat you in the play offs last year. So I ask the question again and hope for a more intelligent comment than

Because I am interested to know how anyone, after only 9 games of a season, is prepared to make a comment like that?

Agree with all that. I would add that we also massively assisted our own downfall by the amount of ball we spilled. The similarities between the two games against the Giants this season are scary.

Although we did contribute to our own downfall, and played poorly, that's not to suggest that this was the only reason we lost. Huddersfield played well (in parts) and were by far the better team. No complaints - just dissappointing that in two games against them we haven't shown up properly. We'll see them again though - at least once, probably more - before the season is out.

no kicking game,no playmaker ,no idea,maybe we are a one man team after all.on the subject of clarke not good enough,but not on his own,bridge should not be selling programmes never mind playing.TS needs take along hard look at team selection,Evans not a winger,Bridge(already mentioned),Atkins cant pass,etc.etc. not a lot of pace in side either so we drop our quickest player, Riley,and play a centre instead.logic lost on me somewhere?also seem to have five steam rollers in our pack and not much creativity.Apart from that we are sound.

and Cas are top of the league. Cas must be better than them, that's how it works isn't it?

We have a better attack than Huddersfield and a better defence. We've played Saints, Wigan and Leeds and they've played us and Wigan. Let's see where they are after a tough run of teams.