He was the best wire winger I've seen in my time and hicks was second best, what I would have given to ha e seen them both in the same team, Charnley and lineham are probably the next 2 and in that order. There have been other good wingers but with more flaws than those mentioned.

It's a tough call to say who was better. Joel was unbelievable as his record shows. But that hat trick hicks scored at Wembley was unreal. Could well be the best hat trick any wire player has ever scored!! Every try took some amazing finishing that I doubt even Joel could've done.

Agreed Joel is probably the best after bevan IMO. Agreed that it's between those 2 recently though right? Both terrific signings by the club, I'm honoured to have seen them both in the pnb.

IMO Hicks doesn’t get anywhere near enough credit for that hat-trick. If that had been scored by Ryan Hall (incidentally his opposite number that day) there would be endless replays on Sky and the Beeb every time cup season comes around.

Possibly the best value overseas signing for us in the modern era. It was his try that took us back to Wembley in ‘09 too.

I rate Hicks the best winger of my time supporting Wire although an important disclaimer is I missed Dessie's first couple of seasons and when I started watching Dessie was still quick but his hands were a bit flaky and he didn't score many tries. Perhaps if I'd been watching when Dessie first joined from Leigh I would put him no.1.

I remember being really pleased when we signed Hicks, because in the 2000s I was a hardcore NRL follower and Hicks at Penrith and Manly was one of my favourite underrated Aussie players. I always thought he would end up in Super League some time and hoped we'd be in for him. Back in the early 2000s he would come up in discussions around who was the fastest player in rugby league, he was exceptionally quick. He'd lost some of that when he joined us but he was just class all round, an incredible athlete, he didn't seem like he was in his 30s, superb in the air, superb finisher, safe under kicks.

He was only here for 3 years and he missed our best seasons under TS, Joel Monaghan benefited from those, Hicks would have scored a ton of tries in that team. Still, he won back to back Challenge Cups and his Wembley hat trick makes him an icon forever.

Hicks was fantastic, and is associated in my mind with an era of really enjoyable rugby. Not just the Challenge Cups but the Greenshields moment, the attack from our own in goal for the Penny try and some important kicks, Hull away after the hooter for one.

But, Joel was a cut above. His finishing was absolutely top class. Just a fantastic player.

It seems a distant memory those wonderful Challenge Cup years. We tonked a much fancied Leeds twice in the finals - great days.

Around that time we really should have got the gf monkey off our backs and since then, we've been getting further and further away.

2011 was the year. We got it all right until the Leeds game. Threw Westwood back in on one leg, he couldn’t move sideways at all. Panicked at the end and just let it slip. We were the best team that season, peaked then and gradually declined.

Just looked back at the highlights of our 2010 CC win against Leeds.

Some great tries, apart from the Leeds one that clearly went 6 ft or so forward from McGuire to Smith (going by the lines on the Wembley pitch) !

And now saints have mastered that art of passing

Didn't we score 1000+ points that season? Superb team.

In the SL era, Hicks & J Monaghan are the best two in P&B for me.

I remember the time it all went wrong in the GF against Leeds when Waterhouse dropped a pass 5 yards out with no one in front of him. I said then, we've blown it.

Think so, yes. Not including the 100+ we put on Swinton in the cup.

I watched that game back in the first lockdown and couldn’t believe we didn’t win it.

There’s a minute that killed us, we were 40 or so out and Briers is put under pressure on the last, so ends up chipping to the right wing. Leeds get it on half way or so, and they find Ablett one on one with Briers on our own line and he scores.

You can see Westwood stand over Briers and give it to him straight. That minute, we lost the game. It’s often said about staying in the arm wrestle and not breaking first, and we did by a panic under kick pressure and changed the momentum completely.