Definitely has the ability but his mistakes are normally due to a lack of concentration. It is in his own hands.

Williams reminds me of Offiah.......he's quick across an open field but doesnt want to get stuck in with the hardwork.

That's some comparison

looks like walt picked a bad week to stick up for williams.

I don't know about anyone else but I've never ever seen this famous Rhys Williams pace.

well all into account i hope the final line up is

hodgo

riley
atkins
ratch
j monas

briers
myler

hill
higham
moz
westwood
waterhouse
harrison (been impressed with him since his return from injury)

carvell
wood
m monas
tyke (deserves it)

sorry for grix, coops etc but reasoning for them 2 is if things don't go there way they have a habit of getting impatient grix trying to rip the ball out in the tackle or throwing silly passes. and coops has the odd high shot.

i think discipline will be the key

I stuck up for him at the game. Carrying the ball away from our line he's brilliant, consistent 10m minimum. I can't put my finger on what his problem is but I'm finding it harder to defend him each time he plays.

Against us, he had a blinder for Cas. According to their fans he's been outstanding. I just don't understand why we don't see this in the P&B? Is it because of the lack of consistent game time or is he just not "top of the league side" quality? At the moment I'm with the former but he's probably got 1 more game to impress this year otherwise he's out the door.

Grix for Tyke for me. Simon's versatility and good form (apart from Friday) makes him the better choice. After missing out in 09 and 10 he deserves his place imo.

i do feel sorry for him but it is not time for sentiment

tyke has been outstanding this year and so has grix (when we have been winning) unfortunately he does lack the patience i have seen for the last year and then some it has always been there that if things don't go our way then he tries to force the issue too much.

my opinion but i would prefer to see tyke in their he has bust a gut to get regular first team place this year and i find it hard to say sorry son but no.

Grix is suffering from Grix Syndrome: one poor game/injury and people retrospectively invent some weird backstory in which he has been inconsistent/poor all season.

For me Grix v McCarthy is a toss-up between two players who've been excellent all season. Simon didn't cover himself in glory on Friday but not many did. I'm sure Tony will make the call based on what's he looking for, who he thinks will do a job and their relative fitness, rather than jerk his knee because Grix gave a shocking pass out on Friday night.

I think that 16 of the 17 Wembley places available are already sorted in Tony Smiths mind and his only undecided spot is between Tyke & Simon G. I don't think that either Coops, Matty B or Bridgey will get a spot.

I think the team will be

Brett.
Riley.
Ryan.
Ratch.
Joel.
Lee.
Richie.
Moz.
Monas M or Mickey H
Gaz
Trent
Super Ben
Benny H

Mickey H or Monas M
Hilly
Woody
Tyke or Simon G (I really don't know who TS will go for)

I'll go with that, although like you I can't make my mind up on the 17th and 18th man. Probably just Grix for me, purely on versatility.

Went full Length for castleford again us, Atkins couldn't catch him.

My 17/18 exactly
Why Hill coming off the bench?
I'd start with him in place of Moz
Hill is our no 1 prop and has coped with everything that's been thrown at him

I think I would start with Moz and big Gaz....with Hilly off the bench....big game experience needed for the start of this one.

I know HiIly has dealt with everything thrown at him so far...I just wouldn't want the occasion to get to him at the start...could be costly.