In answer to the OP, no, TS hasn't made a bad signing. The only one who's been unlucky with injury is Myler - he was great for us last year and in 2010, but since he's been out and GoB's coming through, people have started the Myler-hate-machine all over again. I think if he can work his way back into form, then we'll be much stronger for the play offs than without him.

plays better than your number 12 did v St Albans

If i knew what you looked like i might have done

Thats bob on.

If you want to see how good he is, or how effective he is, take a look at how good our left wing and left centre are doing this year, he's a big part of that, defences covering him and numbering up on him leaving space for Ryan to exploit.

Its exactly the same as when Gillies was here, the majority of people were saying he was bobbins(and forerunner of briers current haircut) but Toa had his career season playing outside of him.

Look at the overall results.

Oh you were the one with the blue top on insulting the ref all match lol, i'll catch you next time mate

Ratchford is a brilliant signing, along with Waterhouse and especially Hill who has exceeded all expectations in his first season in the top flight. Contrary to many on here I see him as a future stand-off rather than fullback.

The only one the jury is still out on is Myler, especially given the fee we paid for him. I just don't see him having a future as our long term number 7, if we want to continue to progress and be winning silverware every season.

I'd keep him at prop.

Ok so if we list ALL of Tony's signings since he signed up who are we rating as the best in order of best to...least best