yep just like Maradonna or Pele arent the worlds greatest ever footballers because they couldnt defend and were hopeless goalkeepers...........

what strange thing to say

Is Rogues not entitled to his opinion? He has after all seen all three players play which is more than most of us.

I haven't seen Bevan play, but I have seen Offiah who was my Bevan, he was a genius and the most exciting player I have seen, but my opinion is the greatest is Ellery Hanley never mind how many tries Offiah scored.

Hanley is better than Offiah because he was a great player not because Offiah couldnt/never played wing fullback or centre and thats Rogues' argument (or rather excuse to not rate Bevan as the greatest).

incidently Rogues I believe Boston said Bevan was "the greatest he played against" he didnt stipulate the specific position just simply the Greatest.

I'll sit back and wait ten years and if Sam tomkins plays all his career at full back I can discount him as a great because other great players will have played a variety of positions....? just like Billy Slaters' not as good as Lockyer because lockyer played fullback and stand off????

It's another very badly disguised chance to have a pop at Warrington whilst bigging up Wigan. It's both boring and tedious.

It looks like the opinion of a person who's witnessed these player's playing.

Don't be so precious.

You obviously don't know him very well then.

He uses bias, misinformation and pettiness in pretty much everythin he says (all of which are displayed in that post)

By the way, rogues, what did bridge do that deserved to be sent off at hudds? God, that was an embarrassing bias bull spew from him.

Sad when a man of age goes senile and spouts boring constantly.

It was a totally unbiased view of three great players (Bevan, Boston and Murphy) In fairness I should probably have added Neil Fox.

IMO Boston, Murphy and Fox were better all round players than Bevan, but that's not deriding Bevan who was a great winger.

What I find amazing is those who are having a pop, who never saw any of those fantastic players in real action.

AS I said previously I saw Bevan play in that Lancashire Cup Final v Saints at Central Park and Saints switched Vollenhoven to the left wing to mark him.
For those who actually went did Saints play in Black jersey with a White Vee that day? It was well over 50 years ago.

To be fair they're having a pop at you and your tiresome, passive aggressive persona on this board, not the players. If you acted your not inconsiderable age a bit more you'd get cut some slack. As it is, you're just seen as an Odemwingie with a bag of werthers originals and a cheeky smile.

Harsh but fair.

Aggressive, get real. I stand by what I said, Bevan was great winger, the other three were better rugby players.

Firstly, I said passive aggressive - look it up if you don't know what it means. Secondly, I was talking about your general posting style on here, not your view on Brian Bevan in respect of which I'm struggling to think of something I care less about.

OK pumpkin?

How childish some users on here are, that a thread about the great player Brian Bevan has ended up into one of throwing childish insults at an older poster who has actually seen Bevan play not just read about him like we have. You should learn a bit of respect.