I think he'd be well suited to RU. Saying that would rather not lose another player to that crap code.

With his defence, he'd be well suited to Union...

i agree...but i could`nt really care less who that shower lose to the union code..

Are you on some sort of medication ?

Joel Tomkins is a class, versatile player with plenty of pace. Average players don't score the kind of tries that he's scored this season both for Wigan and England.

Gotta say his defence is poor.

As a second rower, 7-8/10
As a centre, 3/10

Sam is considering the 'double your money' move to Saracens. He and Chris Ashton are very close mates who has convinced him that with his talent he will be a massive success and household name after a few England caps. From there the opportunity to make money from sponsorship, advertising and tv appearances etc is phenominal compared to RL.
IF he stays in RL he will stay at Wigan, no interest in playing elsewhere or in Australia.
What would you do in his position ??
He even gets boo'd playing for England RL

No to the 1st question.

My opinion (Which we're all entitled to have...) is that he's got into the Wigan team (On a regular basis) because he's Sam's brother. He just ain't good enough to be at one of the top SL sides. If he stays at Wigan next year then he'll be moved into the 2nd row as he's nowhere near good enough as a centre (Defensively very poor and his attack is just OK). If his overall performances don't improve in the pack then I think Wigan will ship him out to a mid table team.

with the way wigan are going they to will be a mid table team so he`ll stay at wigan for life

Jonah Lomu is signing for Widnes

Also agree that Joel Tomkins would be no big loss to RL. Sam tomkins however would be a disaster and however much i and everybody else who doesnt support wigan hates him the RFL need to make sure they keep hold of him in our code.

joel tomkins is an excellent player..... however fadges decision to move his best 2nd rower into the centres effected his game.... there is no doubt about that.... and he did it to accommodate a player from australia on a 1 year contract..... a blatant disregard for the players development..... who could blame him for moving to union.... he saw a player like hansen retain his place while he was moved out into a position he was sometimes cruelly exposed in.

if i was joel tomkins i would have been very p*ssed off.

Joel had to be moved to centre to cover for the departure of Gleeson. Had Gleeson remained a Wigan player Joel would have stayed in the backrow. As it was Joel was the best option Wigan had to cover the centre position.

Hoffman's arrival at Wigan had no effect on Joel's move to centre what so ever.

so would i especially having a brother like ratboy

2 questions......

1. was he your best second rower before hoffman arrived?

2. do you think his game has suffered as a result of his position switch?