Interesting replies. I too would take the Challenge Cups. However if it was a straight choice between one Grand Final and two Challenge Cups, I'd take the Grand Final. I think if it gets to three or more then you've got to go with the cups because you start to create history. Saints have only won one Grand Final in the last eight seasons but I think of them as having been a dominant side because they won four out of five Challenge Cups between 04 and 08.

Without a shadow of doubt it's the CC for me, for all the reasons that have been expressed within these posts. It's also the travelling down to Wembley thing. the post above sums my opinion up perfectly. I think Wigan should get more recognition for being the best team this year in Super League.