bollox as per usual talking out of your backside..the better team won deal with it

I have already said the better team won on another thread.

This thread is saying that ganson nearly cost wire the game, I argue that it wasn't.

right 2 things westwoods try should av been given..and your 1st..we had to wait 5 mins for a try that was`nt and then you still got the penalty...and a 10 yard forward pass for the merecat to score...and he`s well over rated

TBH, I would say he's been the best this year.

I thought Westwoods was 50/50, but I don't understand him going to the screen after awarding a penalty. The forward pass seemed to be one of the few clangers he made today.

I think he'll get the final.

the riley incident , could or should have been given as a knock on its no different than 2 players clashing in a big hit and the ball carrying player losing control of the ball and getting injured in the process and play carrying on, i think ganson was sympathetic as wigan could have had the scrum and six tackles and were on a roll and not give us the first tackle, so to say ganson nearly cost us the game is a bit harsh.

The thread doesn`t say that, it says that Ganson could have cost us the game today in a closer game, i went on to say if that if the game had been a lot closer at lets say 10-8 then i doubt very much he would have given it.

You see many a try given in SL when they clearly wasn`t tries where one of the teams has a commanding lead and then the opposition scores, it seems like a sympathy vote to the team thats getting well beaten, its like the refs are thinking it won`t affect the end result so we will let it go, it could have affected the result today as that try lifted Wigan and gave them big momentum and you got within one score if us with enough time left to win the game.

Ganson never gives forward passes

I must admit that got me completely confused. At first I thought the BBC had got confused and that the video referee was simply looking to see how to restart the game. Yet it kept going on and on, until the replays of checking whether Carmont was in touch or not when putting the ball down.

Surely the Video referee also saw that Ganson blew the whistle and stopped the game prior to Carmont going over.

It would have been the worst decision in the history of RL had it been given AFTER the game was stopped.

without the men in the middle we would have no game , so give the officials a break they have to make split second decisions sometimes, why not take up the whistle yourself if you think you can do a better job. cmon the wire

Ok Steve, btw are you on your blackberry in the changing rooms ?

Refs are full time professionals, they get paid for doing a job they obviously enjoy as they wouldn`t do it otherwise. The decision i refered too wasn`t even marginal, it was a good 5-10 yard forward and thats basic stuff for someone that was very well positioned.

Terribly decision.

I cant believe this guy is rated as one of the best in SL.

Phelps was taken out so it is simply not a try. If that would of been the other way around you would agree.

Even if Saints get there???

may av to watch that again when sober...but as ed as i was i know a forward pass i.e. that overated tool sam tompkins...it was yards forward even you`ll agree with that

Last year??