No one criticised Williams when we were winning. Yet, we lose against Hull - he gets criticised; we lose against Salford - he gets criticised. I don't particularly rate him as exceptional, but Smith thinks he's a better option for first team than Evans or Riley. Yesterday, Briers and Monaghan were furthest from what we expect.

As a winger Riley is better than Williams
He must have done something seriously wrong to Mr Smith to be on the Harlequins naughty step

I criticised him after his first game didn't see what he had over Penny apart from a bigger body mass.

A very ordinary Winger in my opinion.

He made one good return yesterday other than that looked quite laboured.
He has an awful running style and when he is slowing down its like he turns into a man made of jelly. He just seems go completely limp ....

He's an odd one for me.....he could be my John Clarke and will never win me over, i"m in the same boat as nikaed and am fully expecting jim Bowen to tell us in a couple of years look what you could have had.

Actually, Biscuit, I will give you that. You have been consistent. My nobody should have been "almost nobody".

PS Wonder why Smith rates him so much.

He's Shocking.

We've been getting told the same thing the past two years about Riley.

Correct and there will come a time when Williams will want more first team Rugby, and a bit more pay then he will find himself in the same situation as Riley.

At the moment i would expect he's quite cheap which helps, but when that changes you would imagine with our strong youth set up he would be easily replaced by another youngster making the step up to a full time role.

He's not a player we would retain at the cost of putting a dent in the salary cap.Penny's did and Riley is getting to the stage where his experience and youth combined could command an average to decent wage.

Personally prefer Riley... loads more enthusiasm, quick and actually loves playing for Warrington.

Williams, big, fast, when he can be bothered, never looks fired up..and generally appears lazy...

Am I the only one who rates Williams along with Tony Smith then?

Nope, I rate him too

Anyone else disappointed that King didn't show on Sunday?, even woody played on the day his kid was born