apart from the stupid over his head pass with his eyes shut, while being tackled, about 3 mins into the second half yesterday... he had a good game... how salford never scored of that i will never know.

im not convinced about him at all.... i certainly wouldnt be looking to extend his contract.

defensively he is superb though.. i will give him that

still too many silly passes & knock ons for me but getting better

I think so too. He is error ridden. Higham and Clarke are better options currently.

At 9?
No chance..

They are.

I think Monaghan at 9 looked really diverse, and he lasted the full 80, im looking forward to seeing him next week.
Neither Clarke or Higham could play 9 in the NRL at a top side

His defence, whilst good for a 7, is the least effective of our three hookers.

Monas' completion rate = 91.9% (417 tackles, 37 misses)

Higham's = 95.5% (467 tackles, 22 misses)

Clarke's = 93.8% (408 tackles, 27 misses)

He is better at 9, than he has ever been at 7 for us IMO, but he really isn't a top class hooker, and IMo he is 3rd choice for us.

NO!!!

correcto

took manly to a grand final playing there,his semi final performance was immense,it's his best position and i would have him and clarke there all day long,if you spell them correctly they are the best hooking combo in superleague(piddle off saints fans,fatty's past it, thats why he's just a dirty barsteward and roby can't do 80 mins)

Neither can clarke or monas effectively then if you insist on rotating them.