Both, would be a tragedy to get rid of either so soon (perhaps tragedy is a tad over the top)

I'm still not convinced by Riley.
He makes far too many mistakes - glaringly obviouis at full back.

However under the guidance of Smith he should make the grade without being top class.

This I agree with.



That is a load of rubbish.

Cant even believe this question has to be asked.

Riley.

To be honest, Riley!!

Riley FTW

As someone mentioned above, Penny got put in the limelight very early on.
He has more potential, but currently it's gotta be Riley

Riley IMO, He has made some shocking mistakes this year which always look worse because of the position he plays meaning they usually result in us letting the opposition in for a try but generally he has been very consistant, whilst still having the occasional moment of brilliance (That try against bradford for instance).

Penny has speed, and thats about it as far as i can see at the moment?

Both are keen and put a lot in every game.

More potential to lose the ball, make a shocking read in defence or get smashed into touch you mean? Riley by miles, as a neutral.

Both.

Riley. His game has really improved over the last year and will hopefully continue to do so.
Penny has the potential to be a good player but I think it may take a few years for him to get there.