Percival a bigger loss than Lomax for Saints, I also think Lomax needs a surgery so if is at the higher end he might get it done. May be a blessing in disguise for them. I'd rather he got away with it he's been stinking the place out for them.

Is the Lomax incident the one he got sin-binned for? If so, the MRP are basically saying that the ref and video ref got it badly wrong on the night by describing it as just "low-level force", given that they have now ruled it Grade E. As for Sims, if they are being consistent he has to get the same punishment that Vaughan got.

The magic word with refs and the panel, isn't it. Squirrel grip punishment differentials instantly come to mind, as an example where it is not applied.

How on earth did Lisone not get a mention

Good news on Dufty, play him this week then I’m hoping CTW gets a run vs London.

Players tend not to get a ban when the forearm hits the chest.
I can`t post the photo but it`s as clear as day there`s no head contact.
Like I said at the time had he led with his forearm to Russells head at that pace Russell would still be unconscious now.
Richard Silverwood reviewed it and said no case to answer.

https://www.rugby-league.com/article/63 ... inary-news

https://www.rugby-league.com/article/63 ... inary-news

Sims gets 4 same as Vaughan but Chambelin was actually injured hmm. Lomax 3 but a saints fan is saying he did not make contact with the head.

Yeah, buta significant proportion of them believe the disciplinary are the reason they haven’t won any titles in the last 6 years…

To be fair to the disciplinary panel the offence does not discriminate between injured or not.

Law 15.1 (i)
Makes unnecessary contact with a Player who is or may be injured.
Grade F

3 games for an almost identical tackle to Harrison. Ha I bet redvee are fuming.

surprised sims only got 4 games, you'd think it was 4 games for the lift, and something for the head contact that caused the injury

He got 1 game for the head contact he misses 5 games in total.

Could I please back up a bit to this post for a second.

Is Taylor-Wray the player who played the wigan league match before the challenge cup final at full back?

If he was. Wasn't he injured quite badly and out for the rest of the year? He tore something if I remember rightly???
If he was the player. (I forgot the guys name who played. So I am hoping it's the same player) he was a really good prospect for the future and was touted to be the next full back after dufty.
I really liked him and his attitude he had for a debut and I would like to see him get some game time and learn off dufty more in the 1st team.
If he isn't the same player. Does that noy mean we have 2 potential full backs in the academy who are going to be pushing for seniority for the future full back. Which is only good for the club.