I think you must be short of something to do this morning. Total rubbish.
What Joel lacks is pace but for effort and skill he's fine.

This is getting boring now..

I think JM is vastly over-rated. I'm afraid he is a one trick pony.

Last year he was doing well fielding the high kicks and converting
them into tries. That has now dried up, probably because the team
just aren't moving the ball out the same.

I agree with the other post when he is said to "go AWOL".
For effort, energy and positivity he isn't in the same league as Riley.

JM very rarely volunteers to get himself involved making the hard yards
from the line.

But, as long as he's there he'll get picked because TS is known to prefer
"big wingers". Thats why Riley kept being dropped.

Our best two current wingers should be Riley and Evans.

It was also said he lacks a bit of pace !!
Where on earth does the concept of a good winger who lacks pace come from ?

Any winger, given half a yard, is supposed to be able to go the length
of the field at pace. On this criteria alone, JM doesn't qualify.

10 metres out he's a fantastic finisher, he's never going to be a full length super winger but i don't care, i like his role and i think he does it very well.

I've just said something similar of the Riley thread.
There stats are very close together but Riles tackle busts is far greater which to me shows he wants to get stuck in.
Its commented on there that Riles will sit out when Evans is fit, but for me it should be Monnas looking over his shoulder instead.
To throw another angle on it are wingers only as good as there centres???

Well with Myler injured we need to find someone else to blame!!

I personaly do not think he will be with us next year !!!
he said after the AUS. trip that he would like to return to NRL and that he has a opt out clause in his contract at the end of 2012
so I think that says it all !!
but thats just my view

I can't say I would be too upset if Joel has an opt out clause and intends to invoke it. He might give us a bit of height out wide, but, I don't think he is the best winger at the club and there seems no sign in a Matt Kingesque reversal of fortune and form anytime soon.

Not worth a boo though!

Do you actually watch any games? Have you checked his try scoring record since he came to Warrington?

Jesus wept.

I do watch games but I must admit I have been totally underwhelmed, especially of late. After making a decent start, he appears to have lost interest in my opinion rather than kicking on after getting used to SL, his new team mates andf life in Warrington.

I must admit I don't look at the stats to form that opinion, as they can be misleading, again in my opinion.

You of may beg to differ, as of course you are entitled to your opinion.

Tries scored aren't that misleading.

I think that they can be, but, hey ho we could go like this all day long, btw is that all he is there for? Does he match or exceed expectations based on reputation and paypacket which can't be the smallest at the club.

We are struggling for a bit of form all round at the moment and no one would be more pleased than me to see Joel amongst many others to turn that around. I just can't see it with him and judging by some other threads so can one or two others

DAniel Anderson likes him. I like him. Done

And presumably Tony Smith likes him and I will obviously defer to SL's best coach (not necessarily to you Mr Rocket) but I just want/expected a little more.

Happy to eat a bit of humble pie when he delivers.

karl pryce.