One bright spot in an otherwise crap game.

What a sensational signing he is turning out to be. His finishing is world class.

I thought it was a great game. Not the result we wanted but still one of the best attacking games this season. Over 60 points scored and only 4 points I think between us.

A positive

Still got a bit of ‘Wigan’ in him. Sees his a bit too much over not a great deal, just get on with it and play the ball Josh! Might take a season to get it out of him.

Other than that, best signing for the club for ages.

I'm being quite selfish so I'm pleased he's not in the England for Denver.

I agree that he's our best signing for ages, but, might disagree that we need to get 'every' "bit of Wigan" out of him, let's keep that winning mentality if we can?

I'm also really pleasantly surprised, probably based on my anti-Wigan preconceptions, about how he seems to have a positive influence beyond an excellent try scoring record. Top notch so far

Yes there's surely a lesson to learn about the Wigan attitude. We all thought Charnley was an easy figure to hate when he played for Wigan, but his attitude is first class. Fully committed and driven to win, no big ego about himself. Wigan when they were winning Grand Finals had a squad full of these kind of lads.

JC is lovin it, we're lovin it, he water glide any time he wants for me.

Often this "hate" is often envy bubbling up through frustration. He has a winning attitude and one of the best finishers we have had since Hicks.

Don't get me wrong as i thought Chris Hicks was terrific, but JC is twice the player.

Not yet. The marker is down. 3 tries or more are required at Wembley first.

I am basing my opinion on Speed, Strength, defence and all round ability. Are you basing yours on a Challenge Cup final, where he played outside a former Kangaroo and SOO player and a Lee Briers kicking masterclass? I must admit the try where he went through and under 4 defenders was pretty special!!

There's Charnley's 2nd marker then.

Im not sure Charnley is twice the player Hicks was. Hicks was a fine all rounder. He was a better defender than JC. I would argue he was quicker. And he tormented Ryan Hall both in the air and on the ground at Wembley that day when Hall was spoken as being the best winger in the world at the time.

But JC is top player without a doubt. ....

I think we can all agree he is a better option than Russell.