after watching this thrashing is it time to end this magic weekend or plan it better..by that id like to see london or cas or wakey play widnes..may be stick with the hull derby or saints and wigan but what does a hammering like widnes got do for our game..by the way ive been to many magic weekends and enjoyed the event so dont think im being critical but games like this are surely no good for the game...

This weekend should have been Wigan V Wire, Hudds V Cats etc .. ie 1st v 2nd 3rd v 4th and so on.

totally agree it was men v girls today. (no disrespect to the girlies) it would have been far better to match teams who are on the same level e.g. widnes v salford wire v wigan stains v leeds hudds v bradfurt etc.
watching a team like widnes get stuffed by a wire team who "rested" players does nothing for our great game

doing that you`d see more competitive games..still keep the magic weekend and however the league stands 2 weeks before the magic weekend then the 1st plays 2nd 3rd plays 4th etc...love watching the wire win but even i was getting a bit bored with what was on offer today..

Whats your point....?

were there calls for the Manchester Derby to be scrapped after City beat united 6-1....? or similarly Calls for Arsenal to be chucked out the league when united beat them 8-2

Would wigan Rather have played Widnes or Saints....... Well Widnes have already beat Wigan while Saints have lost twice already to wigan..........

hammerings happen in sport, Widnes just got one,


its not a great post.

And we bow to your knowledge and experience of bad posts.

1v2 3v4, so on and so forth should be the way forward, if its continued.

your opinion and your welcome to it but widnes have been walloped in france at our place now mchester..what im saying is can we make these games more competitive..if a mauling takes place then so be it but you wouldnt want 1st v 12th 2nd v 11th 3rd v 10th etc or would you as long as your team wins

you cant organise a mid season fixture simply by how teams are positioned in the league at that moment in time, its ludicrous.........

my experience of bad posts goes up a notch when you arrive.......

All you do Biscuit is say from the off that the Magic weekend is played the week after all the teams have technically played each other once, it gives an indication of roughly how good your form is.

1v2, 3v4 etc is

a) Fair - There's no distance between the clubs
b) Exciting - The league positions could change as a result, you'e making every game the proverbial '4 pointer'

More marketable plus people are getting fed up of derby overkill, how many times will Wigan play Saints this year?
3 times in the league
the quarter final
possibily twice in the playoffs, it's a joke.

Granted Wigan might have to play Saints anyway if they're 3rd & 4th etc but at least then they are evenly matched.

1v2 etc should be the direction to take, todays result (even though i haven't seen the game) was just too easy and not much of a spectacle unless you're a Wire fan.

Its easy, if you select a round before the season starts, then everybody knows, whats the problem...

Don't like the idea of a harder game?

It should have been Wigan v Widnes, would have been a much closer game and Widnes would have had a chance at taking the two points.

Nah, not without GO'B on their team.

I think it should be scrapped, full stop.

I've never seen the reasons for its existence adequately explained/justified.

keep it as it is, with all derbies. It's not our fault that they are rubbish. If it had been 25 or even 10 years ago, it would have been closer. What goes around, comes around.