Not wanting to bring up the ridiculous poll thread hence the new post.

What on earth was he thinking yesterday when he could have simply fallen over the line following that bomb? I may have missed something in the build up but it seemed he just threw out a pass whilst standing on the try line.

Yes, but by posting as you have you have brought it up again. I'm told that he had a good game yesterday. Correct or not?

I thought he had a very good first half, but like all the others, dipped considerably in the second, and also got a few jeers when substituted from mindless idiots.
There were some rough s in the south stand V13 yesterday. Jesus Christ. You always get one who thinks he's hilarious and yesterday was no excption, with some guy shouting "give it McGoldrick" every time Cas had the ball for the full 80 mins.

He played decent enough was a lot more aggresive when bringing the ball in compared to other games this season couple of half decent offloads and got a try and other than the try pass attempt to atkins when he should have kept hold and fell over the try line he did ok maybe could be used in shorter bursts to maximise his impact but he done alright maybe a spell at prop or loose forward may benefit him as his attack out wide on the edges has been average at times this year

He threw the pass because he had a man on him, passing to Atkins was making sure he got over rather than a 50/50 chance of maybe pulling the defender over with him, Atkins dropped it over the line so in that instance Atkins was to blame for the non try... Oh yeah btw i think we got a half century of points in that game.

Just for the record, not that it's important but Orr ripped the ball out as Atkins tried to get it down. Great effort by Orr.

I was in the West Stand and to be fair, Waterhouse would and should have scored had he crashed over the line.

I thought a) he had a good game yesterday and b) it was a really unselfish bit of play. He wasn't to know that Atkins would get the ball stripped.

This, although to be fair I thought he should have been selfish and gone for the line himself.

Let's hope it is the start of a bit of a run of form

My god what a bore he was. Nearly as bad as the guy who whistles every time the opposition make a mistake.

As for the Waterhouse incident. It was a strange one. He seemed to be running on the spot. I don't know if his legs had gone and decided to pass it. He only needed two more steps and to fall over and he'd have scored.

from where i was standing it looked also like it was a high risk pass out the back which could have gone anywhere, when yes all he needed to do was jog forward all of maybe 8 yards and he was in under the sticks , slightly similar to the incident at Hull but a lot more obvious and strange however this one didn't cost us a point , i was happy with his defence and his go forward yesterday. Seemed to put a lot of effort in but in terms of attack i think a lot of people are judging him by the standards of Louis Anderson who was brilliant down that left side. and he is a country mile away. But he does go through a lot of tackles to be fair to him.

-i was stood near the whistler!he does that every game,what a tit he is! also lots were just talking about the man-( yawns) utd game and totally ignoring what what going on on the pitch!! it does me off when your trying to watch the game!! wonder how many of those fans went keighley last wk? not many i guess!

Can tell were Warrington fans cant we. Waterhouse had a great game he is a huge bloke who just needs time to settle. Get off his back. I wonder if the people calling for his blood are same who boo'd and gave King a load of stick as well?

The only way that you can remain as a fan now is if you were one of the 52...

touche