Q1
Eddie - isn't it great what Tony Smith is giving back to the world of rugby league ??

Knob - he isn't the only one Eddie, others do it, some not as much as others


Q2
Eddie - isn't it great that Tony Smith paid his own fare to come to England and has laid foundations at Huddersfield, Leeds and Warrington ??

Knob - Wouldn't it be great if in 10 years time someone was on that course and becomes a successful Warrington coach


What an absolute dick - answer the question and admit that Tony Smith is doing a very decent job and has done since he aarrived in the UK

Phil Clarke never actually answers the question he is asked. Watch next time and notice how he always says something totally different - something he's been thinking up or researching.

knob i turn sound down talks with mouth full of pie.s

I can't listen to the bloke and his opinions.

If he was chocolate, he'd eat himself.

I think he does it to wind people up now, leave him to it.

I just think he's generally a bit of a penis, the sort who likes to read in the bath with a glass of wine.

Pity it's not a Kindle, wired upto the mains whilst charging

Seriously now (for once), I've said this before, Clarke sees us as a threat to his beloved Pies, so he'll give us no credit whatsoever. When we moved into the HJ, and we were still perceived us as a bit of a music hall joke, he'd lavish praise on us. Now, you've more chance of hearing Obama "bigging up" Osama Bin Laden.

Clarke's a widge, leave him to it.

he is just getting the first dig into us before he has to make his way through the south stand on Friday to a barrage of abuse (well deserved mind)

i heard him say charnleys try at hudds early in the season was world class..if my memory is correct it was off a kick and the lad did well to catch it and slide over the line..good try yes world class try NO..and dont forget eddie mentioning AGAIN saints injury crisis..how long into fridays programme before it gets mentioned again

I think you are being a little harsh.

Phil Clarke is a class A kn0b, end of!

I'm going to go against the majority here and say that I find Clarke easy to listen to. In comparison to any other Rugby League 'brain' in the Sky Sports set up, Clarke is light years ahead with his understanding and philosophies of our sport.

He's not bias towards anyone either. Even Wigan. As much as most people have somehow drawn that conclusion.

If there is any bias in Sky Sports coverage of RL, it's that of Eddie Hemmings towards our very own Wire! Don't get me wrong, its nice to hear a pundit praise your own team, but sometimes he may aswell put a Wire shirt on during commentary. Its that blatant.

He isn't being harsh enough.

The sooner BSKYB get shut the better. They have enough 'pundits' already.
Eddie
Stevo
Barry
Terry
Jon Wells
Bill
Angela
Need i go on?