Morley's stiff arm was pure stupid and totally needless. I would be very surprised if he wasn't banned for the Wigan game. Certainly not a captains knock.

Carvell's elbow was more reckless than predmeditated and im hoping that he will get away with a warning.

If both are missing against Wigan then I think we are going to struggle to beat the pies which is such a dissappointment going into that kind of game without both of your frontline props.

It was bit like the old Morley tonight.

We could maybe cope without one both would be very tough.

I couldn't see the problem with the Morley one, so much you do is off the back of your kick pressure, if he didn't go at Sherwin I'd have been more surprised. I thought it was a penalty, at most.

Carvell I fear may get a couple of matches, I thought that was the worse of the two.

Morley hit Sherwin in the back of the head off the ball and should have seen red for it, anything below 2 matches is a joke (in the NRL he would have got 5+)

Carvell knew what he was doing, should have also seen red because it was malicious and he clearly meant to lead with the forearm, again should get at least 2.

But knowing the RFL they'll both get warning letters

We have plenty in reserve in the forward department so i'll say again not worried.

Morley's was a penalty, no more. Nowt wrong with Carvell's.

No problem with Morleys pressure, however he had enough time time to pull his stiff arm out of the way but instead caught the player full on. It probably looked worse than it was but the RFL will be keen to be seen to be doing the right thing.

Carvell could argue that his elbow was raised as protection against the defenders.

No doubt we will see what happens at the disciplinary midweek.

Didn't fatty at Saints get away with something even worst last season (Punch or something)

A jab at the PTB yes

It's not a tickling contest...

I just can't see both getting away it.

Have to wait and see.

Had Sherwin kicked the ball as Morley and just about everyone else watching expected, then the hit would have been across Sherwins chest. Morley was commited to pressurising the kicker and the different 'body shape' after the pass made the incident look far far worse than it was. However, this early in the season I would expect Moz to have a Saturday night off next week.

I though Sherwin ducked slightly into Morleys charge and started to turn his back. Morley did swing but the intent was more to pressure the kicker than hit him with a cheap shot. I thought a penalty was the correct decision.

Carvells could go either way. Leading with the forearm normally goes un-noticed until an injury is caused, as in the case tonight. Certainly was not a deliberate attack but can see him getting a 1 match ban.

I feel we would be unlucky if both players get banned for the Wigan game.

If Carvell does get banned I would like to see Morley and Wood start with a bench comprising of Cooper and Solomona + 2 others. Would also give the option of switching Benny ( or Harrison ) to prop and allow Solomona to have a forage down the centre channels.

Would you say that if it had been ryan mcgoldrick high tackling or using the fore arm on one of your players.
You'd be calling for a 10 match ban .

You mean like the smack in the face that McGoldrick gave King after he was tackled over his own line?