Clark was streets ahead of golden boy walker today. That error from walker hasn't really been discussed much but there's a lot of blame directed to a player playing out of position. Ratchford is bobbins too by the way..and Ben Currie awol today, not for the first time in a big game.

Goodness me, "golden boy" Walker? Yes, he had a bad opening 20 mins or so and that error was terrible but the game swung our way when he and Kasiano returned - shame DP didn't do it earlier.

Walker is the future, Clarke is the past. End of.

Can’t give you an argument.

Not so sure there Morrissey. That was a TERRIBLE error from Walker and other than last week he’s been poor for a few weeks. IMO Clark is still much more effective. Dwyer and Walker fills me with turgid dummy half dread.

You might. The Wire masses won't. After St Helens when Dufty was dropped, Thewlis didn't have a great game at FB and lots of people calling for Dufty to come back sharpish.

It's also taken about four years for people to stop talking about Ashton and the Salford semi final.

Our fans will not tolerate any errors.

Walker effectively cost us the game. His mistake was decisive in putting us a position of chasing the game.

I have no problem with thewlis getting the fb spot. Great to see a player giving it everything when it's hard graft. There's a few in our team that only get involved when the goings good.

Dwyer is an horrendous signing. Really don't rate him one bit.

A shame you couldn't get Clark (yes Clark, not Clarke) to extend.

Goodness me. CHASING THE GAME? There was still 70 minutes to go with a one man advantage for goodness sakes.

The crucial moment was the 6 again after the Bullock try. That was rank stupidity.

Can anyone tell me how wire play, it’s not open free flowing, it’s not defensive I’ve no idea what we try to do and foremost what we’ve done all week in training, Wigan had 12 players but able to make an overlap and score, we had13(I think) and never able to pass and catch(basic rugby) and set wingers free, matty Ashton never gets ball in hand in space unreal, why not get big slow winger who can take ball out like a second rower.

Out of the numerous pages of responses to today this one is the most telling... The style is up the middle and the success of that power game left the team when mikaele went back... It's funny as Powell showed free styling attack with Castleford....today we never attempted to power down the middle and then off quick ruck out to the flanks... Really doesn't help that the centres are pedestrian and neither can give the wingers we have a chance..we were an easy team to defend against with 12 .... Apart from the lack of game management nous today there is also the ages old one of just being mentally soft .... bizarrely despite this we have in the main players to turn it around if only we had the likes of a Rowley to improve there on field skill set