I only made the comparison as both are liabilities, especially under the high ball but seemingly can't do any wrong in the their respective coaches eyes

No but the talk was he was looking at a centre spot, which he had been playing at the early part of the season, when he deputized for ratch he looked like he was going to drop every single high ball, his technique is very very poor.

It makes you wonder how he played at FB for the Giants for that amount of time. Spoke to one of the directors of Swinton at Wembley in the boxpark, he said there may be a chance Ashton may go back to them on loan.

In some defence FMC...he doesn't/hadn't played fb a great deal at Hudds and was thrown in learning much of the role on the job here with our differences in structure.
You could argue something similar for Patton, although he is accustomed to the role at a much lower level, he really only had senior roles in odd games or from the bench playing a forward position.
He like Mamo haven't had the benefit of a settled role preseason. Yes catching a ball is a basic...but not a high bomb....ask Coote.

err, yeah, alright

Yes we did. Made a right meal of it as well limping all over the place.Bit soft for a sportsman but good enough as cover.