Being objective about it given we won, can anyone please explain on what possible grounds that first Livett kick wasn’t given? On the TV they did start to give a possible explanation on the ground that the posts are deemed to extend upwards infinitely beyond their height, which I can see would be relevant if the trajectory of the ball had gone through the vertical plane going upwards, or even connected with the top edge of the post, but it looked to me simply to hit the (very) top part of the side of the post and glance off that to go through the posts, in which case I cannot see the relevance of the “deemed vertical extension” rule. They did also say that the video ref had said that he would not have given it if it had been referred to him. I don’t have any axe to grind here, just keen to understand the reasoning. Can anyone explain?

superb from us today...mean defence and clinical in attack. Roberts controlled the game with a very good display...especially his kicking game. Clarke was his usual brilliant self, as was Hill. BMM running over Tautai was just brilliant.

Sorry to be negative, but Sita had a nightmare in the short time he was on.

I would like to personally thank the Wolves for putting the Gooners out.
Wigan????
Oooh NO!
Everyone can now relax and look forward to a good final.

When is the semi final draw done and Is it tv??? Thanks in advance

After the Hull v Saints game on BBC 2 today.

Weird one with him, he didn’t come on at all in the first half as you would expect him to, then when he did come on lasted less than ten mins I think before limping off. Just wondering whether he carried an injury in to the game, or picked one up during the warm up and we decided to risk t?

We were good. Well executed game plan I think. Forwards bossed it and Clark / Roberts both really good.

Bad day to be a pie eater. Getting dominated and nilled on the beeb, flares thrown on the pitch and ‘that video’.

What video?
Ps "like a lorry over a hump back bridge" Kear on BMM's run over Tautai for the try!

He spent more time on the bike than on the pitch,could be a possibility he was carrying a slight injury,and yes he was limping when he came off.

Good performance for the most part, defence especially.

We went off the boil at times in the second half. Just doing silly things with the ball. But overall a good display.

Thought Clark was immense, Hill and Roberts too