His decision making can be very poor at times

On what biases do you think that?

Very good RD

Gidley has been as good as you'd expect from a 34 year old veteran. Sometimes brilliant, sometimes poor, mostly good.

Yup I feel that there us some very harsh criticism of him.from some on here.

Considering he's been carrying some kind of knock most of the season I'd say he's has been good especially when he is picking up the knocks puttingbhis body on thinking for the team

Gidley is alright.