He is rank average, in the same way that Wheeler is. Why he was picked today I will never understand. Toomany average players = and average season, which is what we have had. Not good enough.

Had he not been a local lad GOB would have been long gone

Watching a Newcastle match just a couple of weeks ago they mentioned the fitness of Gidley. ..they said .After 15 seasons in the nrl he still tops their pre season bleep test.. .. that's quite impressive.

After watching Asotasi most of us fans need a bleep machine ...the useless @#$##@...

Disappointing 'today'? Been disappointing for two years.

I agree with one of the earlier posts, you cant expect your half backs and hooker to perform behind a beaten pack. Wilde put in a good tackling stint, but he was never going to trouble the opposition in the same way that Westwood can. For me the semi final was lost last weekend as a result of Russell's injury and Westwood's citing (with special thanks going to Daryl Powell).

This.

Same team as last week Penny in for Russell we'd have won. G'OB and Myler were great against Cas....mind you so was the pack and the rest of the team now I wonder is there a connection?