Those placing kirmond above Westwood and Waterhouse go give your head a wobble

Well, this season, he's certainly achieved that mantle (both W's are nowhere near their A game this season).

I've wobbled my head. What would you like me to do now?

It's all about opinion. From what I've seen of Kirkmond this season, he's been better than either of our first choice second-rowers.

Whist I'm not a 'boo boy' and Trent will get my support as long as he's here I think he needs to up his game and what better time to do it?

I am also wobbling my head and from what I have seen on SKY Kirmond has impressed me more than our current second rowers.

His workrate and commitment are awesome.

Can I stop wobbling my head now, am getting a headache

Kirmond has EASILY outperformed Waterhouse this season... by a mile

hang on, this is Trent waterhouse who got up to the grand final last year, almost singlehandedly.


I like Kirmond, he's got a lot of hustle, but he's not a game winner, by any means.

If you think Kirmond seems a little lightweight Cat, here's an interesting stat, his weight is 102kg for a back rower

Wire's forwards in order of weight (excluding hookers)

Carvell 113kg
G.Riley 112kg
Hill 108kg
Harrison 107kg
Waterhouse 106kg
Morley 104kg
Cooper 103kg
--------------------------------
Wood, Westwood 102 kg
Laithwaite, D.Bridge 101kg
Currie 100kg
Grix 95kg
Tyke 93kg

Behave... he had a good game against saints... but single handedly?

if that's the case, Mike Cooper also got us to the grand final single handedly.

It appears my "manlove" for Mark Roberts, is being outdone by Cat' for Waterhouse.

Well, Cat, just like comparing two 9 year old girl's love for either JLS' Oritse or Aston, I can definatly say that I love Mark more than you love Trent, so nerrrrrrrrrrrrr

The name of Mark Roberts should not be uttered on a thread about whether we should sign Danny Kirmond.