yeh all or none. i feel like catalan have an advantage as they have a video ref at every home game!!! ...... we don't have to have a tele, just someone there to view the hiffy tries. but saying that if it's ganson video reffing, theres no point having one because he still gets it wrong even when he has video evidence hahahaha. i'm all for it though

Not sure that's true as most of the time the play has stopped anyway.



Can be frustrating, but then we are screaming for their heads when the give a decision without going to the screen, when a Saints player doesn't ground the ball.

I like cricket, and they seem to know how to use the technology to the sport's advantage. I like the review system where if the umpire has got a decision wrong and it's overturned, all accept he is human makes mistakes, and some things are difficult to judge. Perhaps it's not the system that needs to change, it's the fans.

Using the Cricket example is a great shout. That way the video ref can intervene as and when he feels the ref has got it wrong.....maybe....for example.......on forward passes??

I still think they should consider the ref actually being the video ref. On Saturday the ref called for a VR decision on the offside. He knew what "he wasnt sure about". He knew who it was "that he had doubts on". Let there be an engineer who moves the camera/tape BUT let the match ref make the decision.

I don't get this level playing field argument. It has no relevance to other games that some have VR, the important thing it is the same for the 2 clubs within the same game. Where would you stop with the level playing field argument? every game having to be played in the same weather conditions as all the others, same referee as the other games same dimension pitches, same ratio of opposing supporters. The VR is both the same advantage and disadvantage for both the teams within their game.

Sorry what I meant was all the standing about while the VR makes a decision is what annoys me. I quite like the system that Dan Anderson has introduced in the NRL this year, where the referee indicates whether he thinks it should be given or not.