Quote: BogBrushHead "It did get even better (ie - worse decisions) - the video ref can only answer the direct question from the ref .....soft g!t asked "Was there a knock on?" when a ball was stripped by a defender under the post, but went back, and Sale carried on and scored a try ..... video ref, through clenched teeth (he was shown in bottom corner of screen) said "Yes" ..... meaning defender had knocked ball out of attackers hands - but he can't say who did it, only respond to the refs vague question ..... you guessed it - ref, assuming attacker had knocked on, gives scrum defence, and no try !'"
I'm sure I saw something similar a few years ago when the ref asked a direct question and received a direct answer thus awarding a try which was quite clearly not a try. I have noticed a few times since then that some referees ask "Can you see any reason why I should not award the try?" or words to that effect.